Posted on Mar 4, 2023
Battle of Antietam: Clash in the Cornfield
1.03K
51
13
18
18
0
Edited >1 y ago
Posted >1 y ago
Responses: 4
This could have been a decisive victory for the North had McClellan not fought the battle so half-heartedly and allowed Lee to move forces to counter the threats and attacks during the day.
(10)
(0)
MAJ Dale E. Wilson, Ph.D.
My favorite stops during Antietam staff rides are Pry House (McClellan's HQ on a high bluff) and Lee's centrally located HQ just outside Sharpsburg. I take folks to Pry House and point out that a messenger on a fast horse is at least 20 minutes from McClellan's corps COs. We then go down to Lee's HQ where they can see that Lee was about five minutes max from his subordinate leaders. It's very easy after that to understand the outcome of the battle. . . .
(0)
(0)
On the McClellan Go Round- George McClellan and the Antietam Campaign (Lecture)
George Brinton McClellan- one of the Civil War's most controversial and disliked generals- has been the subject of scorn and derision for decades. Frequently...
Thank you my friend and brother-in-Christ MAJ Dale E. Wilson, Ph.D. for posting the background on the September 1862 Battle of Antietam; Clash in the Cornfield
On the McClellan Go Round- George McClellan and the Antietam Campaign (Lecture) -
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WPM4SeXaIuY
Images:
1. CSA General Robert E. Lee –Commander of Army of Northern Virginia
2. 1862 Burnside Bridge over Antietam Creek
3. Federal LTC George B. McClellan, Commander of Army of the Potomac
4. Antietam, MD - D.R. Miller's house on the Antietam battlefield.
5. The 9th New York Infantry Regiment charging the Confederate right at Antietam
6. Antietam, MD - Dead members of the Stonewall Brigade along the fence on the Hagerstown Pike at Antietam, MD
Background from {[battlefields.org/learn/civil-war/battles/antietam/]}
Washington County, MD | Sep 16 - 18, 1862
Antietam, the deadliest one-day battle in American military history, showed that the Union could stand against the Confederate army in the Eastern theater. It also gave President Abraham Lincoln the confidence to issue the preliminary Emancipation Proclamation at a moment of strength rather than desperation.
How it ended
Inconclusive. General Robert E. Lee committed his entire force to the battle, while Maj. Gen. George B. McClellan sent in less than three quarters of his. With the full commitment of McClellan’s troops, which outnumbered the Confederates two to one, the battle might have had a more definitive outcome. Instead, McClellan’s half-hearted approach allowed Lee to hold ground by shifting forces from threat to threat.
In context
Lee invaded Maryland in September 1862 with a full agenda. He wanted to move the focus of fighting away from the South and into Federal territory. Victories there, could lead to the capture of the Federal capital in Washington, D.C. Confederate success could also influence impending Congressional elections in the North and persuade European nations to recognize the Confederate States of America. On the other side, President Abraham Lincoln was counting on McClellan to bring him the victory he needed to keep Republican control of the Congress and issue a preliminary Emancipation Proclamation.
The first Confederate invasion of Union-held territory is not going as planned. After a Union victory at the Battle of South Mountain and a Confederate victory at the Battle of Harpers Ferry, Confederate general Robert E. Lee opts to make one last stand in the hopes of salvaging his Maryland Campaign.
With Federal forces closing in from the east, Lee selects strategic ground near Antietam Creek and orders his army to converge there. A mile east of the town of Sharpsburg, the creek meanders through the hilly but open countryside, good for long-range artillery and moving infantry. The water is deep, swift, and crossable only at three stone bridges, making it a natural defensible location. On September 15, Lee positions his men behind the creek and waits for McClellan to arrive.
On the afternoon of September 16, Union general George B. McClellan sets his army in motion, sending Maj. Gen. Joseph Hooker’s First Corps across Antietam Creek to find Lee’s left flank. At dusk, Hooker bumps into Confederate general John Bell Hood’s division and the two forces skirmish until dark. The following morning, McClellan attacks.
September 17. The Battle of Antietam begins at dawn when Hooker’s Union corps mounts a powerful assault on Lee’s left flank. Repeated Union attacks and equally vicious Confederate counterattacks sweep back and forth across Miller’s cornfield and the West Woods. Hooker sees thousands of his Federals felled in the corn rows, where, “every stalk of corn in the northern and greater part of the field was cut as closely as could have been done with a knife, and the slain lay in rows precisely as they had stood in their ranks a few moments before.” Despite the great Union numerical advantage, Lt. Gen. Stonewall Jackson’s Confederate forces hold their ground near the Dunker Church.
Meanwhile, towards the center of the battlefield, Union assaults against the Sunken Road pierce the Confederate center after a terrible struggle for this key defensive position. Unfortunately for the Union, this temporal advantage in the center is not followed up with further advances and eventually the Union defenders must abandon their position.
In the afternoon, the third and final major assault by Maj. Gen. Ambrose E. Burnside's Ninth Corps pushes over a bullet-strewn stone bridge at Antietam Creek. (Today it’s called Burnside Bridge.) Just as Burnside's forces begin to collapse the Confederate right, Maj. Gen. A.P. Hill’s division charges into battle after a long march from Harpers Ferry, helping drive back the assault and saving the day for the Army of Northern Virginia.
There are more than 22,000 casualties at the Battle of Antietam. Doctors at the scene are overwhelmed. Badly needed supplies are brought in by nurse Clara Barton, known as the “Angel of the Battlefield.” During the night, both armies tend their wounded and consolidate their lines. In spite of his diminished ranks, Lee continues to skirmish with McClellan on September 18, while removing his wounded south of the Potomac River. Late that evening and on September 19, after realizing that no further attacks are coming from McClellan, Lee withdraws from the battlefield and slips back across the Potomac into Virginia. McClellan sends Maj. Gen. Fitz John Porter to mount a cautious pursuit, which is repulsed at the Battle of Shepherdstown.
While the Battle of Antietam is considered a tactical draw, President Lincoln claims a strategic victory. Lincoln has been waiting for a military success to issue his preliminary Emancipation Proclamation. He takes his opportunity on September 22. The Proclamation, which vows to free the slaves of all states still in rebellion as of January 1, 1863, will forever change the course of the war and the nation by marrying the Union cause with an attack on the institution of slavery. Hesitant to support a pro-slavery regime, England and France decline to form an alliance with the Confederate States of America.
After McClellan fails to pursue Lee on his retreat south, Lincoln loses faith in his general. Weeks later, he names Burnside commander of the Army of the Potomac.
FYI SFC Joe S. Davis Jr., MSM, DSL LTC Trent Klug SSgt David M. GySgt Jack Wallace SPC Gary C. PO3 Edward Riddle Maj William W. 'Bill' Price COL (Join to see) SPC Maurice Evans SPC Jon O. SGT Jim ArnoldAmn Dale PreisachCW4 (Join to see) SSG (Join to see)LTC John Griscom LTC David Brown LTC (Join to see)
On the McClellan Go Round- George McClellan and the Antietam Campaign (Lecture) -
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WPM4SeXaIuY
Images:
1. CSA General Robert E. Lee –Commander of Army of Northern Virginia
2. 1862 Burnside Bridge over Antietam Creek
3. Federal LTC George B. McClellan, Commander of Army of the Potomac
4. Antietam, MD - D.R. Miller's house on the Antietam battlefield.
5. The 9th New York Infantry Regiment charging the Confederate right at Antietam
6. Antietam, MD - Dead members of the Stonewall Brigade along the fence on the Hagerstown Pike at Antietam, MD
Background from {[battlefields.org/learn/civil-war/battles/antietam/]}
Washington County, MD | Sep 16 - 18, 1862
Antietam, the deadliest one-day battle in American military history, showed that the Union could stand against the Confederate army in the Eastern theater. It also gave President Abraham Lincoln the confidence to issue the preliminary Emancipation Proclamation at a moment of strength rather than desperation.
How it ended
Inconclusive. General Robert E. Lee committed his entire force to the battle, while Maj. Gen. George B. McClellan sent in less than three quarters of his. With the full commitment of McClellan’s troops, which outnumbered the Confederates two to one, the battle might have had a more definitive outcome. Instead, McClellan’s half-hearted approach allowed Lee to hold ground by shifting forces from threat to threat.
In context
Lee invaded Maryland in September 1862 with a full agenda. He wanted to move the focus of fighting away from the South and into Federal territory. Victories there, could lead to the capture of the Federal capital in Washington, D.C. Confederate success could also influence impending Congressional elections in the North and persuade European nations to recognize the Confederate States of America. On the other side, President Abraham Lincoln was counting on McClellan to bring him the victory he needed to keep Republican control of the Congress and issue a preliminary Emancipation Proclamation.
The first Confederate invasion of Union-held territory is not going as planned. After a Union victory at the Battle of South Mountain and a Confederate victory at the Battle of Harpers Ferry, Confederate general Robert E. Lee opts to make one last stand in the hopes of salvaging his Maryland Campaign.
With Federal forces closing in from the east, Lee selects strategic ground near Antietam Creek and orders his army to converge there. A mile east of the town of Sharpsburg, the creek meanders through the hilly but open countryside, good for long-range artillery and moving infantry. The water is deep, swift, and crossable only at three stone bridges, making it a natural defensible location. On September 15, Lee positions his men behind the creek and waits for McClellan to arrive.
On the afternoon of September 16, Union general George B. McClellan sets his army in motion, sending Maj. Gen. Joseph Hooker’s First Corps across Antietam Creek to find Lee’s left flank. At dusk, Hooker bumps into Confederate general John Bell Hood’s division and the two forces skirmish until dark. The following morning, McClellan attacks.
September 17. The Battle of Antietam begins at dawn when Hooker’s Union corps mounts a powerful assault on Lee’s left flank. Repeated Union attacks and equally vicious Confederate counterattacks sweep back and forth across Miller’s cornfield and the West Woods. Hooker sees thousands of his Federals felled in the corn rows, where, “every stalk of corn in the northern and greater part of the field was cut as closely as could have been done with a knife, and the slain lay in rows precisely as they had stood in their ranks a few moments before.” Despite the great Union numerical advantage, Lt. Gen. Stonewall Jackson’s Confederate forces hold their ground near the Dunker Church.
Meanwhile, towards the center of the battlefield, Union assaults against the Sunken Road pierce the Confederate center after a terrible struggle for this key defensive position. Unfortunately for the Union, this temporal advantage in the center is not followed up with further advances and eventually the Union defenders must abandon their position.
In the afternoon, the third and final major assault by Maj. Gen. Ambrose E. Burnside's Ninth Corps pushes over a bullet-strewn stone bridge at Antietam Creek. (Today it’s called Burnside Bridge.) Just as Burnside's forces begin to collapse the Confederate right, Maj. Gen. A.P. Hill’s division charges into battle after a long march from Harpers Ferry, helping drive back the assault and saving the day for the Army of Northern Virginia.
There are more than 22,000 casualties at the Battle of Antietam. Doctors at the scene are overwhelmed. Badly needed supplies are brought in by nurse Clara Barton, known as the “Angel of the Battlefield.” During the night, both armies tend their wounded and consolidate their lines. In spite of his diminished ranks, Lee continues to skirmish with McClellan on September 18, while removing his wounded south of the Potomac River. Late that evening and on September 19, after realizing that no further attacks are coming from McClellan, Lee withdraws from the battlefield and slips back across the Potomac into Virginia. McClellan sends Maj. Gen. Fitz John Porter to mount a cautious pursuit, which is repulsed at the Battle of Shepherdstown.
While the Battle of Antietam is considered a tactical draw, President Lincoln claims a strategic victory. Lincoln has been waiting for a military success to issue his preliminary Emancipation Proclamation. He takes his opportunity on September 22. The Proclamation, which vows to free the slaves of all states still in rebellion as of January 1, 1863, will forever change the course of the war and the nation by marrying the Union cause with an attack on the institution of slavery. Hesitant to support a pro-slavery regime, England and France decline to form an alliance with the Confederate States of America.
After McClellan fails to pursue Lee on his retreat south, Lincoln loses faith in his general. Weeks later, he names Burnside commander of the Army of the Potomac.
FYI SFC Joe S. Davis Jr., MSM, DSL LTC Trent Klug SSgt David M. GySgt Jack Wallace SPC Gary C. PO3 Edward Riddle Maj William W. 'Bill' Price COL (Join to see) SPC Maurice Evans SPC Jon O. SGT Jim ArnoldAmn Dale PreisachCW4 (Join to see) SSG (Join to see)LTC John Griscom LTC David Brown LTC (Join to see)
(8)
(0)
LTC Stephen F.
Thank you my friend for commenting Maj Joan Marine -and sharing your views on George B. McClellan - overly cautious and failed 1864 democrat presidential candidate.
(1)
(0)
(0)
(0)
If You Visit The Battle Field And Stand In The Sunken Lane Or At The Burnside Bridge It Will Make You Think About The Agony That Troops On Both Sides Endured.
Thankfully Sharpsburg- Antietam Is Not The Tourist Trap That Gettysburg Is And You Can Walk The Battle Field In Peace And If You Look And Listen Real Close You May Even See Or Hear The Phantoms Of The Battle Field
Thankfully Sharpsburg- Antietam Is Not The Tourist Trap That Gettysburg Is And You Can Walk The Battle Field In Peace And If You Look And Listen Real Close You May Even See Or Hear The Phantoms Of The Battle Field
(1)
(0)
SPC James Neidig
MAJ Dale E. Wilson, Ph.D.
I Live About A 30 Minute Drive from There And Drive Through It When I Go To The VA Med Center
I Live About A 30 Minute Drive from There And Drive Through It When I Go To The VA Med Center
(0)
(0)
Read This Next