Posted on Sep 8, 2021
What suggestions do you have for renaming DoD installations honoring Confederate officers?
147K
5.48K
1.75K
846
846
0
Doesn't matter if you agree with this move or not - it's been directed and it's happening. What are your suggestions for renaming the following bases?
- Fort Bragg
- Fort Rucker
- Fort Benning
- Fort Gordon
- Fort Hood
- Fort Polk
- Fort A.P. Hill
- Fort Belvoir
- Fort Lee
- Fort Pickett
- Fort Bragg
- Fort Rucker
- Fort Benning
- Fort Gordon
- Fort Hood
- Fort Polk
- Fort A.P. Hill
- Fort Belvoir
- Fort Lee
- Fort Pickett
Posted 3 y ago
Responses: 811
I have a suggestion, leave well enough alone! You can't erase history no matter how hard you try.
(467)
Comment
(3)
SSG George Emanuel
20 d
I served long before renaming and revising history and even the English language became popular. My pronouns are today, the same as they were when I was in High School. Funny but you can't change my gender no matter how hard you try. Hell, even I can't change it!
As to the bases I believed that they were named as part of the healing process and to accentuate the dawn of a new era of greatness in Our Country.Men of the 10th Alabama and the 20th Maine died on Little Round Top. They were all Americans. We are all Americans.
Renaming those posts is a giant step in once again saying we are a divided Nation, just as we were 150 plus years ago.
Did we not learn anything from 650,000 or more dead?
We aren't going to change the names on their headstones, why would we change the names of bases, and remove monuments?
Just more "woke" nonsense!
As to the bases I believed that they were named as part of the healing process and to accentuate the dawn of a new era of greatness in Our Country.Men of the 10th Alabama and the 20th Maine died on Little Round Top. They were all Americans. We are all Americans.
Renaming those posts is a giant step in once again saying we are a divided Nation, just as we were 150 plus years ago.
Did we not learn anything from 650,000 or more dead?
We aren't going to change the names on their headstones, why would we change the names of bases, and remove monuments?
Just more "woke" nonsense!
(3)
Reply
(0)
(0)
Reply
(0)
Posted 3 y ago
It's humorous to me about how the big Army (and the left side) always tries to change the names of something we've always had & used....
Like the now politically correct term of "DFAC or dining facility".
And yet - we still, and probably will always call it the "Chow Hall"!!!
To me, Ft Bragg has a special place in my heart, soul & memory - and it will always be Bragg, no matter how many different politically-correct left side terms they decide to rename it!
Like the now politically correct term of "DFAC or dining facility".
And yet - we still, and probably will always call it the "Chow Hall"!!!
To me, Ft Bragg has a special place in my heart, soul & memory - and it will always be Bragg, no matter how many different politically-correct left side terms they decide to rename it!
(311)
Comment
(1)
SPC Matt Ovaska
9 mo
I always call it the mess hall. In Virginia folks are not allowed to place confederate flags for more that a year. so they replace the flag every year.
(2)
Reply
(0)
SPC Paul Eiden
5 mo
1SG Mark Rodgers - Spent three years at Ft Hood and am very proud of that location and the name.
(1)
Reply
(0)
SSgt Eric Kelly
2 mo
Renaming bases has nothing to do with the Civil War, the Confederacy or slavery. It’s entirely about disconnecting the American people from their past.
General Robert E Lee was a great man who fought for the wrong side. Had he been born in PA or MI, he would have undoubtedly fought for the Union. That fact is true for virtually every Confederate soldier. Prior to the federal government becoming the all looming behemoth it is today, states right’s and loyalty to one’s state over their nation were actually things.
After General Ulysses Grant ordered Sherman to conduct his scorched earth march through the South, while he pinned down Lee’s forces, the Confederacy still had the will to fight but didn’t have the means. Knowing the South could no longer win the war, General Lee did the only thing he could and surrendered.
What he did afterwards exemplifies why he was great. Lee made great efforts to keep the peace and restore the union. There was a large contingent of southerners who wanted to keep fighting a guerilla war and without men like Lee discouraging such actions and President Lincoln refusing to enact harsh punishments against the losing side, it’s doubtful we would have ever been whole.
Our founders were GREAT MEN who were flawed, as are all men. The vast majority of Confederates weren’t slave owners and they weren’t fighting for slavery, they were fighting for their families, friends, communities etc, which had a unique identity linked with their states. Slavery was only the main driver for a small fraction of extremely wealthy landowners/slave owners. The vast majority of Confederate soldiers were good men with flaws. Men who felt obligated to fight for the wrong side.
The erasure of our history is entirely about destroying our shared identities. Only a few decades back, virtually every American believed we were the greatest nation ever to exist, had respect for the flag, believed in the ideals we were founded upon- freedom, rights, protections, equality etc. Our founders were almost universally revered for their courage, wisdom, foresight etc.
Today poll after poll shows the opposite. Which is entirely a byproduct of attacking our flag, our founders, our national achievements, reframing us as systemically racist, built upon slave labor, colonizers etc
A nation with no shared identity, no national unity, no allegiance from it’s citizens, no sovereignty as our borders have been erased etc is a nation that can be replaced or usurped by outside powers.
General Robert E Lee was a great man who fought for the wrong side. Had he been born in PA or MI, he would have undoubtedly fought for the Union. That fact is true for virtually every Confederate soldier. Prior to the federal government becoming the all looming behemoth it is today, states right’s and loyalty to one’s state over their nation were actually things.
After General Ulysses Grant ordered Sherman to conduct his scorched earth march through the South, while he pinned down Lee’s forces, the Confederacy still had the will to fight but didn’t have the means. Knowing the South could no longer win the war, General Lee did the only thing he could and surrendered.
What he did afterwards exemplifies why he was great. Lee made great efforts to keep the peace and restore the union. There was a large contingent of southerners who wanted to keep fighting a guerilla war and without men like Lee discouraging such actions and President Lincoln refusing to enact harsh punishments against the losing side, it’s doubtful we would have ever been whole.
Our founders were GREAT MEN who were flawed, as are all men. The vast majority of Confederates weren’t slave owners and they weren’t fighting for slavery, they were fighting for their families, friends, communities etc, which had a unique identity linked with their states. Slavery was only the main driver for a small fraction of extremely wealthy landowners/slave owners. The vast majority of Confederate soldiers were good men with flaws. Men who felt obligated to fight for the wrong side.
The erasure of our history is entirely about destroying our shared identities. Only a few decades back, virtually every American believed we were the greatest nation ever to exist, had respect for the flag, believed in the ideals we were founded upon- freedom, rights, protections, equality etc. Our founders were almost universally revered for their courage, wisdom, foresight etc.
Today poll after poll shows the opposite. Which is entirely a byproduct of attacking our flag, our founders, our national achievements, reframing us as systemically racist, built upon slave labor, colonizers etc
A nation with no shared identity, no national unity, no allegiance from it’s citizens, no sovereignty as our borders have been erased etc is a nation that can be replaced or usurped by outside powers.
(1)
Reply
(0)
I think they should name them after Medal of Honor recipients.
(272)
Comment
(0)
PFC Clifford Kelley
6 mo
WHY? Why not leave them as they are? To me changing the names to placate a few is like the timeout cards. Pretty sissified!
(3)
Reply
(0)
PFC Clifford Kelley
5 mo
SSgt Michael Anderson But they were forced back into the United States therefore they were part of your country and your history no matter how much you ignore the fact!
(0)
Reply
(0)
GySgt Jack Wallace
5 mo
SP6 Greg Jetter - Very good point, SP6 Jetter. And that
could happen, for sure.
could happen, for sure.
(1)
Reply
(0)
Read This Next