Posted on Dec 2, 2021
Of Arms and the Law: Revolt against proportionality in self-defence
643
6
2
2
2
0
The link is to a short commentary. There is an embedded link to the 48 page PDF essay.
SGT James Murphy, CPT Jack Durish,
SPC Gary Welch, SGT Mark Anderson,
CPL Douglas Chrysler, Maj Marty Hogan,
1SG Steven Imerman, SMSgt David A Asbury,
MSgt Robert "Rock" Aldi, MSgt David Hoffman,
SSG Michael Noll, MAJ Dale E. Wilson, Ph.D.
SGM Erik Marquez, CW3 Harvey K.
SFC William Farrell, CPL Ronald Keyes Jr
Sgt (Join to see), SSG (Join to see)
SGT James Murphy, CPT Jack Durish,
SPC Gary Welch, SGT Mark Anderson,
CPL Douglas Chrysler, Maj Marty Hogan,
1SG Steven Imerman, SMSgt David A Asbury,
MSgt Robert "Rock" Aldi, MSgt David Hoffman,
SSG Michael Noll, MAJ Dale E. Wilson, Ph.D.
SGM Erik Marquez, CW3 Harvey K.
SFC William Farrell, CPL Ronald Keyes Jr
Sgt (Join to see), SSG (Join to see)
Of Arms and the Law: Revolt against proportionality in self-defence
Posted from armsandthelaw.com
2nd Amendment
Self Defense
Civil Affairs
Posted 3 y ago
Responses: 2
3
3
0
1
1
0
Because any other legal conclusions is disastrous. If we allow the law to value one life over another, everything becomes relevant and questionable.
Sure, he was robbing you. But the day before he saved 73 schoolchildren from a burning bus. And yesterday you cheated on your taxes. Now his life is more valuable than yours, therefore you have a diminished right to self-defense. Etc.
In the eyes of the law, all lives MUST be equal, lest we get into a ridiculous, complex, and SUBJECTIVE valuation which has no REAL bearing on whether or not you were justified - in that moment, in those circumstances, and at that location - in firing.
Sure, he was robbing you. But the day before he saved 73 schoolchildren from a burning bus. And yesterday you cheated on your taxes. Now his life is more valuable than yours, therefore you have a diminished right to self-defense. Etc.
In the eyes of the law, all lives MUST be equal, lest we get into a ridiculous, complex, and SUBJECTIVE valuation which has no REAL bearing on whether or not you were justified - in that moment, in those circumstances, and at that location - in firing.
(1)
(0)
Read This Next
Continue with Facebook 
Continue with Google