Posted on Dec 14, 2017
Kennedy announces intent to increase aid to South Vietnam - Dec 14, 1961 - HISTORY.com
2.62K
13
5
9
9
0
Posted 7 y ago
Responses: 2
If JFK hadn't been assassinated, our involvement in SEA and the history of Viet Nam would probably have been very different. At least, that's the conclusion I've reached based on an interview with, and information from, John A. McCone, Director of the CIA during the Kennedy and Johnson Administrations.
Question: "What should Johnson have done differently in his conduct of the war?
McCone: "In the first place, he should not have conducted it. You see, Kennedy made a mistake when he accepted the recommendations of Walt Rostow and General Maxwell Taylor to violate the 1954 agreement which restricted the military assistance group provided for the South Vietnamese to, I think, 850 military personnel, and that is the number Eisenhower held to. He said, "An agreement is an agreement, and we're not going to increase that military assistance group." And Eisenhower stood steadfast against the recommendations of the joint chiefs of staff, who were insisting that it be increased."
"Eisenhower, among other things, in addition to standing by the treaty, said: "If you increase the United States presence in South Vietnam, then it will become our war. It won't be the South Vietnamese; they will walk away from it." Now Kennedy won the 1960 election by a narrow margin, and one of his cries was that Eisenhower had been soft on communism in Vietnam and soft on communism in Cuba."
"The first thing that he did was send Maxwell Taylor and Walt Rostow over to examine the situation in South Vietnam. And they came back recommending that the military assistance group be increased from 800 or 850 up to 25,000. Kennedy embraced that, but after a year he saw the folly of that agreement. He was prepared to withdraw a very substantial amount of our presence in South Vietnam -- possibly getting down to 850. I don't know.... If my memory serves me correctly, he had ordered the first 1,000 men withdrawn. But I am not sure about that. But Johnson, on the other hand, ignored all of this, and he just accepted it as a war that we had to win."
"Reflections on a Life in Gov't Service
John A. McCone"
http://globetrotter.berkeley.edu/conversations/McCone/mccone-con5.html
Question: "What should Johnson have done differently in his conduct of the war?
McCone: "In the first place, he should not have conducted it. You see, Kennedy made a mistake when he accepted the recommendations of Walt Rostow and General Maxwell Taylor to violate the 1954 agreement which restricted the military assistance group provided for the South Vietnamese to, I think, 850 military personnel, and that is the number Eisenhower held to. He said, "An agreement is an agreement, and we're not going to increase that military assistance group." And Eisenhower stood steadfast against the recommendations of the joint chiefs of staff, who were insisting that it be increased."
"Eisenhower, among other things, in addition to standing by the treaty, said: "If you increase the United States presence in South Vietnam, then it will become our war. It won't be the South Vietnamese; they will walk away from it." Now Kennedy won the 1960 election by a narrow margin, and one of his cries was that Eisenhower had been soft on communism in Vietnam and soft on communism in Cuba."
"The first thing that he did was send Maxwell Taylor and Walt Rostow over to examine the situation in South Vietnam. And they came back recommending that the military assistance group be increased from 800 or 850 up to 25,000. Kennedy embraced that, but after a year he saw the folly of that agreement. He was prepared to withdraw a very substantial amount of our presence in South Vietnam -- possibly getting down to 850. I don't know.... If my memory serves me correctly, he had ordered the first 1,000 men withdrawn. But I am not sure about that. But Johnson, on the other hand, ignored all of this, and he just accepted it as a war that we had to win."
"Reflections on a Life in Gov't Service
John A. McCone"
http://globetrotter.berkeley.edu/conversations/McCone/mccone-con5.html
Conversation with John McCone, page 5 of 6
Harry Kreisler interviews John A. McCone on his life and careers in business/engineering and government service: 1987 & 1988
(1)
(0)
SP5 Mark Kuzinski
I was in 10 grade when this happened and all of us felt that this "Conflict" Would be over bu the time we graduated.
(0)
(0)
Read This Next