Posted on Feb 11, 2015
Thoughts: Chelsea Manning now writing for The Guardian?
8.12K
32
35
3
3
0
Politico reports Chelsea Manning now is going to write op-eds at The Guardian. From the article:
"[Manning] will write 'occasionally from Fort Leavenworth prison on the subjects of war, gender, and freedom of information' for the British newspaper's American site, [editor-in-chief, Katharine] Viner wrote in a staff memo. Manning will not be paid."
Questions: 1) What do you think of The Guardian giving Manning a platform? 2) Do you believe what she says will represent what most transgender service members and vets believe and value? 3) As a commentator, is she representing more than herself -- is she a true representive of trans community in general?
http://www.politico.com/blogs/media/2015/02/the-guardian-hires-chelsea-manning-202383.html
"[Manning] will write 'occasionally from Fort Leavenworth prison on the subjects of war, gender, and freedom of information' for the British newspaper's American site, [editor-in-chief, Katharine] Viner wrote in a staff memo. Manning will not be paid."
Questions: 1) What do you think of The Guardian giving Manning a platform? 2) Do you believe what she says will represent what most transgender service members and vets believe and value? 3) As a commentator, is she representing more than herself -- is she a true representive of trans community in general?
http://www.politico.com/blogs/media/2015/02/the-guardian-hires-chelsea-manning-202383.html
Posted in these groups: 
Transgender
Security
Transgender Security
Posted 10 y ago
Responses: 14
5
5
0
The last I checked prisoners were not supposed to have a way to make money outside of jobs in prison and since she is a resident of the Correctional Barracks at Fort Leavenworth how is this possible.
(5)
(0)
CPT Zachary Brooks
SGT Jim Z. I think we should. Teach the prisoners how to be contributing members of society in some capacity (we always see the license plates cliche in movies) to help deter their costs and teach them to be a productive member of society. Explain to them the specifics of where their salary is going so they understand how their salary goes towards their bills.
It has merit for actual rehabilitation.
It has merit for actual rehabilitation.
(0)
(0)
(1)
(0)
PO1 Autumn Sandeen
SMSgt Minister Gerald A. Thomas, SCOTUS's decision in Turner v. Safely gives Manning the right to free speech. There's a four prong test, and it appears Manning has the right to write op-eds under that standard.
http://www.firstamendmentcenter.org/prisoners-rights
http://www.firstamendmentcenter.org/prisoners-rights
(0)
(0)
(1)
(0)
3
3
0
1) The guardian is a Private Press Organization. They are Profit based, and doing what they feel will make them money.
2) I don't think Manning has enough life experience overall to represent "most" of any demographic, whether it be Trans, or Vet.
3) There will be a perception that Manning is, which is worse. No one person can represent any demographic. President Obama cannot represent all Black Men, or all Men, or all people from Illinois, or all Americans, or all Democrats. Asking if manning is a "true rep of the trans community" is asking to fall into the "no true Scotsman" logical fallacy.
2) I don't think Manning has enough life experience overall to represent "most" of any demographic, whether it be Trans, or Vet.
3) There will be a perception that Manning is, which is worse. No one person can represent any demographic. President Obama cannot represent all Black Men, or all Men, or all people from Illinois, or all Americans, or all Democrats. Asking if manning is a "true rep of the trans community" is asking to fall into the "no true Scotsman" logical fallacy.
(3)
(0)
2
2
0
This may not be a popular answer, but I think Chelsea should not be allowed to write for the newspaper that he/she gave all those U.S. secrets to. American authorities ought to clamp down on that, put a stop to it. She should not be a "commentator" from inside the Disciplinary Barracks at Fort Leavenworth. I think that's just wrong -- whether it's about trans-gender issues, war, or freedom of information - whatever the topic.
(2)
(0)
Read This Next
Continue with Facebook 
Continue with Google