Posted on Nov 8, 2013
Tension between National Guard and Active Duty Army?
214K
1.82K
350
203
203
0
I have served in both capacities and even on active duty while in the Guard. I constantly hear Active Duty gripe about the National Guard, and yet even worse I have also heard National Guard gripe about the National Guard. I am very pound of my unit's achievements in the past and while I have served with them. We have fought and lost great men just like our counterparts in the Active Duty Army. I make sure to crush it where I find it. We didn't get the name of Roosevelt's SS for nothing. We literally shredded the German's 1st SS in WWII and later deployed twice to OIF. <div><br></div><div>How do you approach this situation, whether you're in the National Guard or Regular Army? Or are you guilty of doing this? I was in the past. </div>
Edited 10 y ago
Posted >1 y ago
Responses: 201
I spent 29 years on active duty, and I think that we often had unrealistic expectations of National Guard Soldiers. National Guard soldiers are often 10 to 15 years older then their active duty counter parts, and often not in as good a physical condition. Their physical condition was a function of age, and physical training - which isn't part of most civilian occupations. But the aspect that was often over looked, is that when you had a National Guard unit deploying with you, there were always a bonus effect. You had professional electricians, plumbers, carpenters, mechanics, lawyers, doctors, nurses... all of those National Guardsmen had years of experience from their civilian jobs - and that always was a wonderful bonus... and helped us solve real world problems. The National Guardsmen that I worked with were good men, dedicated and brave soldiers - but they were different from active duty soldiers, and in some ways better.
(264)
(0)
CSM Todd Smith
I served in the CTARNG for 25 years. We usually had active duty observers and raters during our annual training. Before 9/11 the AC treated us like a red headed stepchild and treated us poorly. However after 9/11 the attitudes did a 180. The AC leaders realized that they can't go to war without the NG. As COL Roach stated we bring civilian skills to the fight that the AC doesn't have. For instance a friend of mine was a COL in the RIARNG. He is a high level executive in banking. When he deployed to Afghanistan his job was threat finance: find the enemy's money and take it from them. What MOS is that in the Army?
(0)
(0)
SPC James Fitzpatrick
These problems date all the way back to 1940, when the Guard was nationalized by FDR, in preparation for WWII. A thorough discussion is in "The US ARMY in WWII, Chief of Staff:Prewar Plans and Preparations".
(0)
(0)
LTC (Join to see)
CPT (Join to see)
There are exceptions. I ran 5 k relay races at FOB warrior in Iraq OIF 3/4 with my CSM. We were the 2-116th Cav BDE.
I did a 300 on my APFT. I ran a 13:40 2 mile run. I got a 299 on my last APFT in 2018. I was 56.
Some ARNG/,USAR are not fat bodies. I was one of the old guys that freaked out 20somethings. I was extended scale 318 AFFT in 1997 MP BOLC at age 34. I ran a 12:30 2 Mile.
I used to do the BMI taping for others
I passed the ACFT in 2021 just before I retired at 59. My 2 Mile time was 15 min.
COL Jon Thompson LTC (Join to see) LTC John Shaw CH (CPT) (Join to see) MCPO Roger Collins CMDCM John F. "Doc" Bradshaw 1SG(P) Dean Mcbride (MPER) (SPHR) SFC James Baber LTC Trent Klug
There are exceptions. I ran 5 k relay races at FOB warrior in Iraq OIF 3/4 with my CSM. We were the 2-116th Cav BDE.
I did a 300 on my APFT. I ran a 13:40 2 mile run. I got a 299 on my last APFT in 2018. I was 56.
Some ARNG/,USAR are not fat bodies. I was one of the old guys that freaked out 20somethings. I was extended scale 318 AFFT in 1997 MP BOLC at age 34. I ran a 12:30 2 Mile.
I used to do the BMI taping for others
I passed the ACFT in 2021 just before I retired at 59. My 2 Mile time was 15 min.
COL Jon Thompson LTC (Join to see) LTC John Shaw CH (CPT) (Join to see) MCPO Roger Collins CMDCM John F. "Doc" Bradshaw 1SG(P) Dean Mcbride (MPER) (SPHR) SFC James Baber LTC Trent Klug
(1)
(0)
(0)
(0)
I believe that there is a time and a place for some good natured ribbing and joking between branches, services and components. With that being said, I have served with members of the National Guard in both Afghanistan and in Iraq and to me and my Soldiers, the only difference was the patch on the shoulder. It's a non-issue in my book.
(165)
(0)
GySgt William Hardy
As an active duty Marine, I was stationed at Patch Barracks in Stuttgart, GE and was surrounded by mostly soldiers, but Air Force and Navy also. One day this Army CPT came in my office and said, "SSgt Hardy, I was told you might have nails I could get from you." My response was, "Sorry Sir, I ate my last ones for lunch!" Yes, there is a place for good natured ribbing, but when it comes to differences between active and reserve, there should be no difference. If you run across a bad unit, that unit is bad, not the whole system. I have run across both good and bad in active and reserve status.
(24)
(0)
LCDR (Join to see)
Mid-deployment, we had a visiting CO and CMDCM. There was an active-duty E6 who said, "What's up with all of these reservists?! They may flip burgers in their civilian career, and then they come over here (in theatre) and don't know their jobs!" Mind you that most of the room were reservists including our CO, XO and CMDCM. Thankfully, the visiting CMDCM mentioned that his entire command were mobilized reservists "who can go tow-to-tow" with any active duty command he had been at.
My personal opinion is that after you are deployed for a few weeks or months, everyone settles into their jobs, and besides patches, you can't tell who is active, reserve or National Guard. Many active duty don't have extended interaction with reserves or National Guard, but it is definitely more than a "one weekend a month, two weeks out of the year" commitment.
My personal opinion is that after you are deployed for a few weeks or months, everyone settles into their jobs, and besides patches, you can't tell who is active, reserve or National Guard. Many active duty don't have extended interaction with reserves or National Guard, but it is definitely more than a "one weekend a month, two weeks out of the year" commitment.
(18)
(0)
LTC (Join to see)
LCDR (Join to see) - LCR, I am sure that many reservists have over 3 years active duty, over 3 deployments since 2001. Due to the recent downsizing talk of reducing the active army by 40k, the active component will have to work alongside the reserve/guard units because of sequestration of $100 billion over the next 10 years. We have come back to the Donald Rumsfeld 'go with what you got' mentality. Rumsfeld said that Kuwait in late 2004. I was not at that meeting where he answered the Louisiana ARNG soldier's complaints about lack of up-armored vehicles with them at Camp Udari.
(9)
(0)
Like many of my counterparts here in this thread, I have served in the AD and am now a reservist. There is some good old fashioned ribing, but there are those out there who think of the Reserve and National Guard as substandard. What COL Roach says in this speaks volumes, but another aspect is this, We "part time" Soldiers are able to complete missions in combat with training only 2 days a month and 2 weeks in a year and are able to keep up and sometimes out perform our AC counterparts. There are thos out there that see this, however I do not believe we will ver totally get out of the "Nasty Guard or Reserve" mentality. Only those that served side by side with them will have a new respect for us. I amproud to be a reservist. We are able to juggle the Military, our civilian job, family school etc. AC is able to concentrate on thier full time Military occupation. Be proud of who you are, AC, Reservist or National Guardsman because in the end we all are on the same team fighting the same fight!
(119)
(0)
SFC Ronald Miller
I served 4 years active duty 67-71 during V.N. They held us back from going to V.N. and sent 60 of us MP'S from Fort Gordan GA. to Inchon, Korea the day after the Pueblo ship was captured by North Korea. In 73-77 I was in the Army reserves. 77-81 National Guard at Midway Airport in Chicago. I got out for 14yrs. then joined the Guard as a SSGT. in a National Guard stinger unit. 96-2000 transferred to a CID unit in Lakeland, FL. for a yr. and then transferred back to an MP company in St. Petersburg, FL. I retired on my 60th birthday in July of 2007. I served alongside many good men and women during my 26yrs. and am proud that I did. I have respect for all Members of our MILITARY no matter Active or Reserve, or Guard. We all served in the Military subject to getting sent to wherever we were needed? WE are BROTHERS in Uniform!
(4)
(0)
A1C Medrick "Rick" DeVaney
SGT Glenn E Moody -
"OMG & HOLY SH*T"~ Your Recruiter LIED To You?
HOW Un-Fa-King Forgivable. ~~ LMFAO ~~
"OMG & HOLY SH*T"~ Your Recruiter LIED To You?
HOW Un-Fa-King Forgivable. ~~ LMFAO ~~
(0)
(0)
(0)
(0)
Read This Next