Why are so many NCOs afraid to hold Soldiers to the standard?
I am going to reiterate and support many of the prior statements about people being afraid of "catching a case", part of that mentality is fault of senior leadership not currently but prior to OIF/OEF when they gave the power to the PVTs and took it from the NCOs to do their jobs. Next the friendship thing, that is the NCOs fault, when I 1st came in during the early 80s, my NCOs were on a friendly basis, not necessarily friends, but they took care of us and looked out for us as per our safety, ensuring we weren't abused by others and doing the right thing, but they also enforced the standards and made sure that as Soldiers we knew the difference between being friendly and doing what our NCOs conveyed per orders, taskings, etc. This leads into one of the problems with many NCOs today, a majority have been promoted too fast in the name of filling slots and trying to give incentive to retain, which is what has caused this issue, because most have not had proper mentoring, teaching or time to learn how to be an NCO like most of us old dogs from the pre-9/11 phase or even pre-Clinton phase, as I think it started to show itself as a result of the RIF of the mid-90s. We currently have many E6/E7s with less than 6-9 years, which less than 15 years ago was an anomaly, and we have E5s with barely 2-3 years in, with each of those ranks that type of timeframe is no where near enough for those positions as far and knowledge and military maturity no matter how much some on here may argue that they are mature enough for their rank, no you aren't not in reality for what many are doing regularly with standards and misdeeds being conducted.
A decade plus of two wars has also had a major effect on the standards as well, while I am not a big advocate of enforcing minimal grooming or uniform standards in a combat zone, the issue is that many of these Soldiers and the young NCOs have been to the combat zones more than they have been in garrison so that has not allowed them time enough to have the mindset of what is differential between combat and garrison, this is one of the big reasons to not have the accelerated promotions and fast track promotions of the past decade, not saying some of the 6/7/8/9 NCO rank promotions have not been warranted for actions during deployments and in performances while being forced into leadership positions from fatalities of comrades, but they have again not had the time experience or mentoring/training they needed for the rank and positions.
I want to re-hit another aspect of the "catching a case" issue, with the political environment currently from RIF and the media coverage of improper behavior, the environment has been created that you are guilty and have to prove your innocence instead of innocent until proven guilty as it should be, so all it takes is someone making a claim whether true or not and an NCO or Officer (yeh right) career could be over with, so many are staying clear of anything that could affect their career instead of doing the hard right over the ignoring easy wrong. And the young NCOs are not being mentored or trained to do the right thing or how to be a good NCO because many of those that should be doing the aforementioned duties are worried about losing their jobs so if they don't do what is right by their subordinates it sets everyone up for failure, 1st the junior by not receiving the proper mentoring and training that could cause them to be the one being cut by RIF to the senior who are not doing what they know to be right to keep them from being RIF'd and replaced by their younger counterparts, it is a double edged sword for everyone all the way around.
The whole system is broke right now and until we do some house cleaning in Congress and the senior leadership in DOD, and make the cuts at both those levels it is only going to continue to get worse in all aspects of what we have been discussing.
Thanks to all who have listened to my long and detailed rant and dissemination of and old Soldier with 27 years of seeing the system go through many changes in the last 3 decades.
SSG Woods,
Thanks for the candid response, as I had mentioned about not saying deployed accomplishments haven't warranted some of the promotions, but also that their seniors are not giving proper mentoring and training, sort of just throwing them to the wolves at times to learn it the hard way, which in some instances can be good in the long run if you are given the time to mature for the rank given as well as nurturing that is needed along the way.
And it is true about being impossible to learn everything, but that is also part of your superiors responsibilities to help guide you in the right directions for the areas that you may be lacking or not knowledgeable in, especially with the constant changes as you mentioned it will always be a learning process, but if you are pushed too fast towards the next ranks you are being set up for failure not only for yourself but for the ones you will be leading if you are not afforded the seasoning and learning time as well. Now with that said there are the rare Soldiers that can learn and move right into those ranks and positions because of natural ability and comprehensions of the necessities, but as I said that is a rarity, you may be one of those exceptions, if so I applaud and encourage you to move forward, but I also caution to do not only what is best for you, but for your subordinates and the Army as a whole as well.
I think you know which you are and can be and will do the right thing from what I have read from you many times before, good learning and teaching as well to your juniors.
SSG Woods,
Short comment in reference to your post. It is a same that you have to hear seasoned NCOs talk about how much you may not know or other NCOs may not know when it comes to things such as Drill and Ceremony.
We have been at war for over a decade, roger, got it. We have shifted from Garrison Operations to Tactical Operations, roger, got it. But as the Backbone of the Army is not the responsibility to police up our NCO Corps and ensure that standards are passed on? If we have NCOs in our ranks that are falling short in some areas we should pull them to the side and Train, Coach and Mentor to ensure that our art of being NCOs is not lost but preserved.
I didn't make my rank as fast as others but I will still pull NCOs to the side and ensure that what I know is passed along because one day I will move on from the Army but what I know should be passed to ensure that the standard is and always be the standard.
This is just how I feel.
Also, if you feel that there are areas that you lacking in, find that NCO that is the embodiment of the Creed and learn, learn, learn.
That is all we can do. Be, Know, Do use to mean something, I say we bring it back. It's not a catch phrase, its a three word description of who and what we are.