1
1
0
Posted 5 y ago
Responses: 1
First, that was a powerful moment. And my wife and I had a bit of a discussion over it. When I was younger my Dad told me once: "If a gecko wants to claim that its great great great great grandfather was a Brontosaurus - why not grant it the benefit of the doubt? It doesn't harm you, and it makes them feel better. But...you are living now, and people won't judge you on your great great great great grandfather's exploits, successes, of failures. Live your life."
It seems that personal history does matter - the History of the Jews is one of continuing exile or exclusion, why? My Dad felt the sins of the Father should stay with the Father...so, for example, he never passed on his prejudice for English People (his Father and Mother were Irish), yet one of my brother's wanted to go over and fight during the troubles. I told him: "You are from Cleveland!"
One of my favorite Comedians ( Bill Burr) says that the stories you hear as children are the ones that last the longest. And when you hear stories when you are older they don't stick as much. I hate that we keep repeating the past, for we can't change any of it. You can't even change the clothes you wore ...yesterday. If you want a different tomorrow, you have to start today, and that changes the past. As far as I can tell, that equations doesn't change.
Maybe the kids should know their family history, and decide how much of it they want to embrace...or not. I know many people before Social Media and the Internet made everyone's past a present moment- where they escaped a past they didn't like, or started over as a "different person"- not so sure that can be done today. But anyways, Kathy and i had a running conversation - like this long ramble...because we watched a man who felt cheated out of his heritage, while building his own life story.
It seems that personal history does matter - the History of the Jews is one of continuing exile or exclusion, why? My Dad felt the sins of the Father should stay with the Father...so, for example, he never passed on his prejudice for English People (his Father and Mother were Irish), yet one of my brother's wanted to go over and fight during the troubles. I told him: "You are from Cleveland!"
One of my favorite Comedians ( Bill Burr) says that the stories you hear as children are the ones that last the longest. And when you hear stories when you are older they don't stick as much. I hate that we keep repeating the past, for we can't change any of it. You can't even change the clothes you wore ...yesterday. If you want a different tomorrow, you have to start today, and that changes the past. As far as I can tell, that equations doesn't change.
Maybe the kids should know their family history, and decide how much of it they want to embrace...or not. I know many people before Social Media and the Internet made everyone's past a present moment- where they escaped a past they didn't like, or started over as a "different person"- not so sure that can be done today. But anyways, Kathy and i had a running conversation - like this long ramble...because we watched a man who felt cheated out of his heritage, while building his own life story.
(2)
(0)
PO1 William "Chip" Nagel
SGT Kevin Hughes Love It, I'm one of the Family Historians for the Nagel Clan. I Understand the Importance of Family History "Heritage" I'm Quite Proud of My German, Scottish, English, French Heritage and Happy to Discuss any of those Histories.
(1)
(0)
SGT Kevin Hughes
PO1 William "Chip" Nagel - My Uncle Bill filled that role...then my brother John took it over, briefly, my wife even looked into it. But there are so many side trails. That old Irish stereotype kind of creeps into play. I did find it interesting when My wife showed me my own family tree; Apparently all four of my Great Grandparents Spoke only Irish, and only one put English down as a second language. By the time I was born, we were watered down to domestic beer with no Guiness. ( I don't drink, and boy, in my early Irish Catholic upbringing that was not a plus. LOL)
(1)
(0)
PO1 William "Chip" Nagel
SGT Kevin Hughes - While all My Grandparents were born in this Country they were raised in a St Louis Metro where the Dominant Language was German and English was a Secondary Language.
(1)
(0)
SGT Kevin Hughes
PO1 William "Chip" Nagel - Is that why all the beer companies are in St. Louis? I know the Germans in Cleveland had a few breweries, and they built all the Catholic Churches - and kindly gave half of them to us Irish folks. The Greeks built the Orthodox Churches...and kindly gave two of them to the Russians!
(0)
(0)
Read This Next