Avatar feed
Responses: 13
1stSgt Nelson Kerr
7
7
0
It is a, so far, incurable infectious blood born disease. Besides the threat to th others the battlefield poses a threat even to the person infected, battlefield are known for getting bloody
(7)
Comment
(0)
AA Joseph Moody
AA Joseph Moody
>1 y
Another consideration as well is that active duty often exposes people to situations (or exposes them to people who have been in those situations) where they are going to be in contact with disease and interesting forms of single and multicellular life, you know things like mold, fungus and good old fashion substandard living conditions, food of questionable providence....I'm sure we could think of a few hundred other things to add to this list.
(2)
Reply
(0)
Avatar small
MSgt Nondestructive Inspection (NDI)
3
3
0
Nothing against him getting a job as a DoD civilian but in the military part of it is deploying. He would be non deployable.
(3)
Comment
(0)
1stSgt Nelson Kerr
1stSgt Nelson Kerr
>1 y
that is the important thing here.
(3)
Reply
(0)
Cpl Software Engineer
Cpl (Join to see)
>1 y
I agree and I actually agree with kerr on something.
(4)
Reply
(0)
MSgt Nondestructive Inspection (NDI)
MSgt (Join to see)
>1 y
For every non deployable service member some other poor sap has to go in their place.
(0)
Reply
(0)
Avatar small
MSgt Steven Holt, NRP, CCEMT-P
2
2
0
So lemme see if I got this correct.... Goober with a serious medical condition wants to joint up where he can put more people at risk of contracting his condition because, gosh darn it, he's always wanted to be in the military. Is that about the gist of it? In the words of COL Sherman T Potter, Commander M*A*S*H 4077, "Mule Muffins!"

First, I have serious concerns about his judgement. The article doesn't elaborate but I'm going to assume he didn't become HIV positive through contaminated blood/blood product transfusion. That leaves the two most common routes of exposure of IV drug abuse and unprotected sexual activity. Given the high risk of STD's in today's society, it calls into question his ability to apply critical thinking and risk avoidance. Both are traits needed for leaders in the military. He appears to have neither. He poses a risk to fellow service members even at garrison. Combatives training (and sometimes even normal PT events) can be bloody affairs. I've walked away from Combatives with a bloody nose by virtue of participation (I shoulda ducked instead of weaving! lol) Hell, even a paper cut in the office could potentially expose others to a health risk. We're not exactly talking a case of the "cooties" here. He states he was an NCO before leaving the service to pursue a law degree. Apparently he did not learn the lesson of putting his Soldier's and the Army's needs before his own.

Second, assuming he is allowed to join, he would be permanently prohibited from deploying and most likely prohibited from assignment at certain overseas locations. The ever shrinking military only has so many billets for personnel. The more non-deployables we have, the more burden is placed on a shrinking pool of eligible members for deployments. With heavy ops tempos and back to back deployments being cited as reasons valuable soldiers are choosing to ETS, placing an ever higher likelihood of deployment doesn't pass muster.

Third, how the hell did we ever get to a point where the courts are dictating law and policy to the nation? I thought that was the purview of the Executive Branch (POTUS) and the Legislative Branch (Congress) to enact laws with the Judicial Branch (SCOTUS) having the burden of making sure they meet Constitutional validity. Pretty sure I learned that in Civics class in high school. By resorting to having the courts bully DoD to make exception for one spoiled entitled brat, it sets a bad and potentially dangerous precedent to allow other medically unfit individuals to join. The US military is the World's premier fighting force primarily due to its adherence to higher standards. Lowering those standards puts the very safety of the Nation at risk.

DoD has not, nor should it ever be, an equal opportunity employer. Having Asthma, diabetes, gout, flat foot, sleep apnea, ADHD, hypertension, COPD, and epilepsy are all conditions that could bar enlistment. I feel bad for this individual. HIV is a devastating disease that often eventually proves fatal (usually due to other complications). Why should one person be granted an exception because of selfish reasoning?
(2)
Comment
(0)
SFC Kelly Fuerhoff
SFC Kelly Fuerhoff
>1 y
He already is IN the military. He wants to become an officer and he can't because the HIV diagnosis makes him non deployable. It says he found out after his second deployment - maybe it was contaminated blood. Or maybe a sexual partner lied to him. You don't know that he was stupid. Maybe he had a partner cheat on him and not tell him...that happens. While I was with my ex husband he was the only person I had sex with - he wasn't faithful to me though. I didn't find out until later on - so I could have easily gotten a STD but I wasn't being promiscuous.

You say you read the article but you missed the key part that he is already IN the military and deployed twice before he found out he had HIV.
(1)
Reply
(0)
MSgt Steven Holt, NRP, CCEMT-P
MSgt Steven Holt, NRP, CCEMT-P
>1 y
SFC Kelly Fuerhoff - My apologies. I did miss the part where it states he is still in the Guard. I thought I read where he had gotten completely out to attend college. That's what I get for reading in haste after being awake for nearly 24 hours.

I don't agree with his decision to deliberately place himself in a position to potentially expose others. A case of the Clap is one thing. HIV is something entirely different.

With being permanently non-deployable, today's shrinking military just doesn't have room for those members. A great many people like to throw the word "fairness" around. How fair is it to keep forcing others to deploy or take OCONUS assignment while he stays stateside? Eventually the resentment will build and he will find himself in an even more uncomfortable situation of being shunned and disliked (as if being an HIV positive lawyer isn't bad enough) by those continuously away from home because they are forced to pick up his deficiency.

I realize I sound cold-hearted in this. I feel bad for the guy. He's certainly in a very difficult situation which very well may be through no fault of his own. Maybe he's the victim of a cheating spouse/partner as you pointed out. It doesn't change the fact he now has a condition DoD has deemed incompatible with commissioned service.
(0)
Reply
(0)
Avatar small

Join nearly 2 million former and current members of the US military, just like you.

close