Posted on Apr 2, 2015
RallyPoint Team
359K
5.46K
1.25K
64
-44
108
101215 f 7917e 086
* Please vote in the survey here *

Note: I am a RallyPoint member (served in USAF for 5 years) and wish to remain anonymous, because I need to be 100% honest that I feel the DoD is discriminating against non-retirees like me. Please tell if I am right or wrong here.

While I was serving in the USAF (5 years active), I enjoyed shopping at AAFES locations and online as well. It saved me a lot of money and the deals always seemed good. Now that I am a civilian, and did not hit retirement before I got out, and am not rated 100%, I can’t shop at AAFES anymore. I think that’s flat out wrong. I put in my time as much as anyone.

I know there are going to be RallyPoint members who respond with, “You only did 6 years, and you knew AAFES rules full well.” Well, here is what I say to that.

I did a 7-month tour in Iraq at FOB Taji. Easily left the wire more than 10 times. I hurt my shoulder due to wearing my kit a lot (30% rated). I did as much as most retirees, including retired grunts. I deserve AAFES access as much as any retiree. I respect that retirees served a little bit longer, but I did 7 months in Iraq.

Am I justified in thinking I should get full AAFES access?

Please vote in the survey below. Thank you.
Posted in these groups: Main benefits 1335181026 Benefits
Avatar feed
See Results
Responses: 625
CMSgt Senior Enlisted Leader
491
488
3
Edited >1 y ago
I would really love to come to your defense as a brethren AF member, but I simply can't. I do not mean in any way to denigrate your service, but no.

A couple points of flawed logic here:
1) To say, "I did as much as most retirees, including retired grunts" is flagrantly absurd. Especially when there are retirees that spend their ENTIRE career deploying... for a year at a time... going outside the wire daily... humping rucks... Do you see where I am going with this?

2) "I respect that retirees served a little bit longer, but I did 7 months in Iraq." A *little* bit longer? You floundered between 5 years and 6 years in, so they served 14-15 years more. That is a lot more.

Please enjoy all the benefits that Target and Walmart offer. They sometimes have better prices than the BX.
(491)
Comment
(3)
MAJ Defense Foreign Liaison Officer
MAJ (Join to see)
9 y
CMSgt (Join to see) - Back in Afghanistan, doing what I do. Life is good.

I hope life is treating you well!
(0)
Reply
(0)
SSG E Williams
SSG E Williams
>1 y
You don't think it's right because you don't qualify under the Regs....shame, should had stayed in and got that benny like we others did that put up with far more than you did and longer!!!!
(2)
Reply
(0)
SSG Will Phillips
SSG Will Phillips
>1 y
As well it should be. I have never asked for anything that I did not earn.
(1)
Reply
(0)
SPC Medical Specialist
SPC (Join to see)
6 y
AAFES has the worst prices anyway. They asked me to test their new website about a year or two ago and I thought their prices were outrageous. I told them they can keep their website and I'll never shop there unless they make their prices more competitive. I was also not impressed with their offerings.

According to their rules, only active-duty military, retirees, National Guardsmen, Reservists, and 100 percent disabled Honorably Discharged Veterans are authorized. All other Honorably Discharged Veterans can only use the online store. For the Anonymous OP you have the option to use the online store. They used to not even allow that years ago.
(1)
Reply
(0)
Avatar small
CPT Bruce Rodgers
266
266
0
Oh I don't know, I did 18 years and two deployments plus I have lost the use of my legs so I didn't get full retirement, but your right we are same.
Hahahahaha
I know brothers who are a lot more disabled than me and our disabilities were not from a kit. So with much deference to your service I find your attitude of entitlement insulting
(266)
Comment
(0)
SFC Aaron Lewis
SFC Aaron Lewis
8 y
Don't feel left out MSgt, $24,000, actually $22,500 is pre tax and every year it will go up due to pay increases. This number also doesn't take into account disability rating or VA. Todays retirees are absolutely making more than those ten years ago and in 10 years I will look at younger generations differently also. What SSG Bozo is not accounting for are the changes that take place every year that modify our retirement perspective. Yes every year new retirees are making a few more bucks due to their pay at the time of retirement. But to think that there are no insurance issues or co pays means he hasn't began to prepare to leave active duty. Every year there are more and more stories of possible changes to retirement, or benefits. Luckily most of the Idea Fairies are shot down but there are a few that still get through. I will retire soon and become the third consecutive generation of military retired men in my family. Each one had completely different retirement standards. Some better but most not so much. Before long it may end up a gold watch and a pat on the ass out the door, welcome 401k Army. As far as shopping at the PX, well it gives us a tax break, great, its not like the prices are any better. A $100 item still costs $100, the only difference is we cant claim anything purchased there on your taxes, so its the same outcome. Every year the Exchange is becoming less and less advantageous for saving. I live 1/2 mile from mine and I never go there because their stock sucks and the prices are not saving me anything. I look at it like SAM's Club, My service provides my membership. Retirees have earned the right to shop at the PX, if nothing else because they retired, period. Anyone that would even question that would have to be extremely selfish, or just a self entitled prick. Yes there are a lot of prior service that I feel should have been retired not just discharged. That's not my lane to determine. If you left service honorably and proud with your head held high, whether you have Exchange privileges or not, thank you for your service and I hope your country is taking care of you and your family. For those of you that didn't, or feel entitled because your super special and you want to celebrate it, Wal-Mart has a club also, they give out cards and everything. Have a ball.
(2)
Reply
(0)
1px xxx
Suspended Profile
8 y
SFC (Join to see) - No copay??? What the hell are you talking about....tricare has copays for retirees ......either that or i'm getting screwed over
1px xxx
Suspended Profile
8 y
SFC Aaron Lewis - Just FYI there has been no pay raise in retiree pay or VA disability pay for three years......it's not a guarantee never has been.......it's one of the reason that the longer you've actually been retired the less your retirement is worth....it does not keep up with the cost of living.
SFC Aaron Lewis
SFC Aaron Lewis
8 y
MSgt Ronald Stacy - I admit don't have a full handle on the flow of retirement pay yet. I was just using an example. I have no elusions that retirement pay wont cover me for the rest of my life. Unless I love refrigerator boxes... Thanks for the info though.
(0)
Reply
(0)
Avatar small
TSgt Joshua Copeland
146
146
0
@Anonymous, you lost me with this single comment: "I respect that retirees served a little bit longer, but I did 7 months in Iraq." My legitimate thought on this is "so what?" Not saying that service in Iraq (or Afghanistan, HOA, etc) is something to dismiss, but lets be clear here, if we are going to go based on where and how long someone served, I would start with COMBAT Vietnam, Korea, and WWII vets FIRST, than move to those who served in country, so on and so forth.

I note that you make a fuss over being in Iraq and "going outside the wire" once every 2.5 weeks or so (7 months x 4 weeks =28 weeks, divide that by 10 (the number of times you say you went outside) and rounded to nicer number), so If we lowered the criteria to going outside at least once a week, you would still be mad, even thought they clearly are "owed" it more than you. How about we limit it to just folks with CAB, CAM, CAR, CFMB, CIB, and awards with "V" devices etc?

My BL point here is this, stop trying to justify your service for benefits by creating even smaller and smaller classes of "veterans" just so that you can fit in the box. Be proud of your service, enjoy the benefits you earned, don't complain about the ones you failed to meet the well established requirements for?

MAJ (Join to see) Capt Richard I P. SSG James J. Palmer IV SFC Mark Merino CMSgt (Join to see) SMSgt (Join to see) SSgt (Join to see)
(146)
Comment
(0)
TSgt Joshua Copeland
TSgt Joshua Copeland
>1 y
PO2 George Ermeling , are you implying that I have mommy issues?
(1)
Reply
(0)
PO1 Rexford Dundon
PO1 Rexford Dundon
>1 y
I retired from the Navy in 1 Nov 2011, 20 years and 7 days of active duty service, 13 of those are sea duty. I'm sorry, unless you were medically separated from the service through NO fault of your own, NO you don't deserve to get what someone that put in 20+ gets. This isn't Congress, where you do your 2 years and your now "vested" into the Congressional retirement system..
(13)
Reply
(0)
SSG(P) Instructor
SSG(P) (Join to see)
>1 y
I left the wire 10x....to go pee. I deserve it damn it. Give me bennies.
(7)
Reply
(0)
SFC Josh Billingsley
SFC Josh Billingsley
>1 y
I spent over 13 years in, just recently got out and I have no complaint that I can't use the PX/BX. I plan on joining the reserves in the near future, and maybe I'll take advantage of those benefits again. but consider this, those folks who spent 20 years or more, or were 100% disabled EARNED that lifelong right. The pX is not a privelege that can be extended to every has been who joined the ranks, if so where does it stop? The kid who gets kicked out of boot because he quits during his PT test? Why stop there? How about our DEP-loss soldiers-they swore an oath of enlistment, they just never served. If this privilege is extended to everyone, it will soon not seem like much of a privilege at all. One of the benefits of this benefit is that it is not available to everyone and anyone. Those who use it have earned the right to use it. Let it go, you had your 5 years to use it. I really don't think I would publicly share that my "kit" hurt my shoulder. I got a buddy who's still serving who is still getting shrapnel removed from his shoulder, and he's still proudly serving in the ranks. please take your pity party elsewhere, you're not going to get much sympathy here.
(5)
Reply
(0)
Avatar small

Join nearly 2 million former and current members of the US military, just like you.

close