Posted on Jan 10, 2015
What do you all really think about the RallyPoint Web Site?
3.93K
42
14
5
5
0
Personally I like the site, I like how it is member oriented in the fact that you have to know some one or prove service to be included in a lot of the aspects of the site. I also like how it allows members of the military to re-connect or to exchange intel on jobs, homes, news, and military events. Plus it gives us a place where we can bash the VA and every one else understands ;)
However, the cons I see is navigation is brutal. Might as well give an LT a compass, map, and a grid. (no offense LT's, you heard it before) Also what are your concerns about security of the site? What if any pertinent information can you stand to have compromised... Specially with world events of today. How can your information on this site be used to compromise our our brothers and sisters down range. I'm sure that Rally Point takes every measure to secure the information here but even billion dollar corporations have information stolen. Wjat are your thoughts on these pros and cons?
However, the cons I see is navigation is brutal. Might as well give an LT a compass, map, and a grid. (no offense LT's, you heard it before) Also what are your concerns about security of the site? What if any pertinent information can you stand to have compromised... Specially with world events of today. How can your information on this site be used to compromise our our brothers and sisters down range. I'm sure that Rally Point takes every measure to secure the information here but even billion dollar corporations have information stolen. Wjat are your thoughts on these pros and cons?
Posted in these groups: 
RallyPoint
RallyPoint
Posted 10 y ago
Responses: 8
7
7
0
SSG John Dombrowski, I agree with you about the pros of RallyPoint. It's clear that it is filling a void that has existed for quite some time. I guess the founders of RallyPoint saw that void and filled it. Kudos to them.
As for the navigation issues ... They're constantly working on improving the site and addressing issues such as navigation, making it easier to find things, topics, information. I've seen improvements in my short time here (about four months).
And regarding security ... You're right to be concerned about security, OPSEC, etc. We've all heard the FBI/DHS warning about identifying oneself as military or a veteran on social networking sites. I think the way RallyPoint forces people to verify their DoD affiliation before allowing them full access is a good step. No site is perfect - as you correctly point out - but I'm comfortable with the security of RallyPoint.
As for the navigation issues ... They're constantly working on improving the site and addressing issues such as navigation, making it easier to find things, topics, information. I've seen improvements in my short time here (about four months).
And regarding security ... You're right to be concerned about security, OPSEC, etc. We've all heard the FBI/DHS warning about identifying oneself as military or a veteran on social networking sites. I think the way RallyPoint forces people to verify their DoD affiliation before allowing them full access is a good step. No site is perfect - as you correctly point out - but I'm comfortable with the security of RallyPoint.
(7)
(0)
SGT Steven Montgomery
I know the answer to my question so please don't blast me. We make it a competition so people will have an incentive to participate and earn points to see how high up the ladder they can get. Seems a little 'off the beam' to me for a real pure military discussion website. I may be way off base, just my opinion.
(1)
(0)
SGT Steven Montgomery
I don't get on here and follow the various threads as many of you. I understand the security concerns and agree with that but I see this as something of a 'game' because the more points you get the higher you are rated. I'm not sure of the point behind that other than to simply make it a game. If it's truly a discussion website, why the need for making it a competition?
(1)
(0)
LTC Yinon Weiss
SGT Steven Montgomery - Among other things, points give people recognition for their contributions. We believe in recognizing people based on the merit of their contributions, not just based on their rank, position, or title. It is not a competition, but merely a reflection of the recognition that some members receive.
All cars have speedometers to tell you how fast you are going, but it doesn't mean that every time you drive it's a competition with other cars. The points are only a competition if you decide in your own mind that it is.
All cars have speedometers to tell you how fast you are going, but it doesn't mean that every time you drive it's a competition with other cars. The points are only a competition if you decide in your own mind that it is.
(1)
(0)
5
5
0
I love the site, and the networking, and the forums. Very impressed by the vast majority of members, their comments, and the dialogue.
I think using the app is very tough and beta still (as can be expected) and think an option to delete comments should be available so we don't have to just see "comment withdrawn".
I also feel like if, as a member, you can access others profiles and tag them in posts, you should be able to message them without adding them as a contact. Lastly, the ability to block certain individuals would be nice.
All that being said, I think it is an exemplary way of filling a void, of engaging past, current, and future servicemembers, and I applaud the creators and administrators.
I think using the app is very tough and beta still (as can be expected) and think an option to delete comments should be available so we don't have to just see "comment withdrawn".
I also feel like if, as a member, you can access others profiles and tag them in posts, you should be able to message them without adding them as a contact. Lastly, the ability to block certain individuals would be nice.
All that being said, I think it is an exemplary way of filling a void, of engaging past, current, and future servicemembers, and I applaud the creators and administrators.
(5)
(0)
3
3
0
I have participated in may Internet discussion sites and can attest to the fact that there is more civility and common sense practiced on RallyPoint than on all the others combined. That says a lot about the RallyPoint audience.
RallyPoint itself? Meh. It's okay...
RallyPoint itself? Meh. It's okay...
(3)
(0)
Capt Richard I P.
CPT Jack Durish I'm not sure if the stinger at the end was a joke, but this is intended as one (truly not intended to offend).
That comment sounds a lot like "I really like the people at this new club where we all meet up and talk about relevant topics and professional development, the clubhouse itself and the roads that get us there? Meh, they're ok"
That comment sounds a lot like "I really like the people at this new club where we all meet up and talk about relevant topics and professional development, the clubhouse itself and the roads that get us there? Meh, they're ok"
(0)
(0)
CPT Jack Durish
Actually, my final comment was an honest response to the original question. Take a look at InkaBinka.com and you'll see what's possible in a modern website
(0)
(0)
Read This Next
Continue with Facebook 
Continue with Google