Posted on May 6, 2016
I saw this cartoon on a friend's Facebook page and immediately felt the need to defend the military. How would you react if you saw it?
707K
3.44K
1.14K
267
267
0
Responses: 813
Here they go again. Remember the question: What would "they" do if "they" gave a war and nobody came? This nonsense was used to indict everyone of us who answered the call to serve during the Vietnam War (keeping in mind that the majority of us who served were volunteers). Despite the public outpouring of affection for those who serve ("Thank you for your service") many of us who served in Vietnam harbor a suspicion that the kind of attitude portrayed in this "comic" is still prevalent.
(259)
(0)
Tawnya Ostlund
A1C Melissa Jackson - but the fact that you would and could be at anytime. That's what counrs. I'm still thankful for u
(0)
(0)
Tawnya Ostlund
SGT David Cho -Sir. I give a darn you and all servicepersons are the backbone of our country and without you we would fall. I thank you everyday of my life for your service. You all our true hero's for protecting me and my family.
(1)
(0)
Tawnya Ostlund
SN Kevin Townsend Sir.. I'm still thankful for you wanting to do it. What would you prefer us to do?
(0)
(0)
SN Kevin Townsend
Tawnya Ostlund - that's a tough one to answer. To most people that don't know me, I've gotten where I'll just reply with a simple handshake and a "thanks for your support." To my family and close personal friends, I've pretty much told them not to bring it up.
(0)
(0)
I personally take issue with this meme. In my experience we generally used less force than we could have even based on ROE. Had we really not cared there would have been no reason to kick in a door we could have leveled the neighborhood or village. We lost kids more often than not because of that restraint. This fits a narrative that allows some to rationalize their perspective which is based on judgment from the safety of a couch watching a war on television. This alone does not really provide context and is a cheap shot. Hopefully the person who posted this served, if not and they believe this then they should have joined and changed the paradigm they believe is true. Choosing to not serve then judging those who do makes one part of the problem. That is my opinion and I am sticking to it.
(252)
(0)
SGT Jimmy Gravitt
Respectfully, I disagree. Had I believed the war unjust THEN enlisted, especially during the "Surge" as a 12B, then logically I would be volunteering to participate in this war. So, if I killed someone, that would really be murder, whether state-sanctioned or not. It's easy to take comfort in the fact that a good portion of the people that we killed, whether the war was just or not, were horrible people who should have been killed.
(3)
(0)
MAJ David Potter
SGT Jimmy Gravitt - I do not take your not agreeing as dis-respect and think debate is great. But I am confused? Were you a 12b who enlisted during surge? And do you think the war was unjust? Or if you thought the war was un-just? And if in war did you violate ROE? Participate in war crimes? Not sure how serving in combat and killing is murder?
(5)
(0)
PO2 Chris Niles
I think it's more an issue of the depiction of our troops killing innocents in order to pay for college
(3)
(0)
Read This Next