Posted on Sep 25, 2014
Cpl Aaron Nelson
47.2K
365
287
7
7
0
During my service I wasn't deployed to combat areas due to the timing of my enlistment. After I EAS'd, I accepted Jesus Christ as Lord. With all the potential threats to our Country now, I've had to reconcile the thought of taking a life in self-defence. What are yall's thoughts on the matter?
Posted in these groups: Air combat art 0134 Combat2000px christian cross.svg Christianity
Avatar feed
Responses: 91
SGT Richard H.
34
34
0
Out of the eight most commonly accepted versions of the Bible, only two of them say "Shall not kill" as a commandment. The other six say "Shall not murder". BIG difference.
(34)
Comment
(0)
SGT Richard H.
SGT Richard H.
>1 y
MAJ Carl Ballinger and Cpl Justin Sowell I've neen following this discussion and I think there's a slight semantic difference getting in the way.
What I'm getting from Maj Ballinger is that the fighting isn't in the name of God (which I agree with) and from Cpl Sowell, I read the point not so much that the fighting was in the name of God, but rather that Christians may very well have been wiped out, had they not fought as a unified group (which I also agree with).
(2)
Reply
(0)
Cpl Justin Sowell
Cpl Justin Sowell
>1 y
SGT Richard Hanner I think that is exactly it. MAJ Carl Ballinger brings up some very great points from a biblical perspective, and mine are based on a more historical perspective. The Bible denounces violence, and I agree with MAJ Carl Ballinger that Jesus would never condone violence in his name. God loves all men. Even those we see as enemies. However, my argument is that sometimes your very survival depends on your will to fight which you can see throughout history. I don't at all think God wants us to fight, but I don't think he expects us to just roll over and die either. It's a ruthless ugly world sometimes. Survival of the fittest still exists just on a much larger scale.
(0)
Reply
(0)
SGT Richard H.
SGT Richard H.
>1 y
MAJ Carl Ballinger I doubt that Christianity was ever in any danger of getting wiped out, but you know the old saying "all it takes for evil to triumph is good people doing nothing". Here's an interesting watch with regards to the Muslim version of the crusades:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=t_Qpy0mXg8Y
(0)
Reply
(0)
SGT Richard H.
SGT Richard H.
>1 y
Haha, no I don't believe it is....unless Edmund Burke wrote the bible.
(1)
Reply
(0)
Avatar small
1px xxx
Suspended Profile
I cannot speak to Christian theology, but as a Rabbi I can speak to this issue...here is the thing:

in the Ten Commandments, number 6, in the Hebrew is לא תרצח - lo tirtzach - Do not MURDER

If it said "Do not KILL" the Hebrew would be לא תהרוג - "Lo Taharog"...

So, while I don't know what the NT says about this, I can say categorically that by the Ten Commandments, you are NOT sinning if you take a life in war, self defense, or in a court mandated death sentence.

CH (CPT) Heather Davis
CH (CPT) Ephraim Travis
CH (MAJ) (Join to see)
SMSgt Minister Gerald A. Thomas
2LT Patrick Lime
LCDR (Join to see)
1LT Sandy Annala
MAJ Contracting Officer
MAJ (Join to see)
>1 y
MAJ Ballinger, well said, sir. Please accept my apology. I do tend to get passionate about the Word of God. With that said, let me make a resource available to you that will take your time in the Word to the next level. My pastor, along with a select group of our church body in North Atlanta, actually developed and marketed a scripture study tool that makes "word" study within the WORD an amazing process. When you have a chance check out WordBloom. The application uses several different translations, to include the NASB (I like it as well) and the Greek. Check it out - WordBloom.com. I've been out of touch for a few years, working for the Army in Charlotte and now living in the Middle East and the software lets me stay engaged with my church family back home. WordBloom actually allows you to simultaneously search the Bible in your language and in the original language. It automatically translates your search into original languages and connects it to other related thoughts in Greek, Hebrew, and Aramaic. It makes studying the bible fun. Trust me, I'm not marketing here just passing on a resource to another brother in Christ.
(0)
Reply
(0)
1px xxx
Suspended Profile
>1 y
David, I just took a look at your program. I'm not sure what it offers. I tried putting in a Biblical Hebrew word, and it just sat there looking at me.

How does it use Hebrew?
MAJ Contracting Officer
MAJ (Join to see)
>1 y
Well, sir. I believe what you get with the "look see" version - what you get to play with as a teaser - is still the Beta version and not the full functioning application. I'd be happy to connect you with my pastor who was the software developer behind WordBloom. He's a great guy and one of my closest friends and I know he'd love to discuss God's Word with you. Let me know and I'll get you two connected offline. But to give you a layman's answer - WordBloom allows you to see what the Bible has to say about "X". People always ask questions like..."What did the Bible really say about Murder?" Type in Murder and you get scripture references in your chosen translation plus links to the original languages - H, G & A.
(0)
Reply
(0)
1px xxx
Suspended Profile
>1 y
Ok, sounds good, thanks...
COL Strategic Plans Chief
16
16
0
I don't. If you believe and serve, you need to make an informed choice. I asnwered a calling, a profession, and I know I belong here. Call it fate, predetermination...whatever. If the commandment to not kill is a hard and fast thing...then you're doomed. Accept it. If it isn't, and there is small print that didn't make the tablets, then no one knows about them. Seeing as how Moses came down from the mountain and ordered the majority of the people slaughtered (take a look at the order he gives when he returns and finds his people worshiping false idols and cavorting around like heathens)...he pretty much immediately breaks some serious rules. But...we don't know. We do what is ours to do, for a noble purpose, and we concern ourselves with it and only that, and we trust that it is for the good. The Lord will sort it out.
(16)
Comment
(0)
COL Strategic Plans Chief
COL (Join to see)
10 y
**shrug** I stole that last line (paraphrasing) from Marcus Aurelius. Stoicism blends nicely with Christianity if you approach it correctly.
(2)
Reply
(0)
PO2 Todd Voge
PO2 Todd Voge
10 y
Cpl Aaron Nelson and COL (Join to see) , your comments have to be some of the most reasoned and thoughtful I have seen on this topic. God used the sword many, many times in order to bring safety and security to His people. As you say Cpl Nelson, "as long as I am not committing murder for the sake of killing I am safe." I believe that statement wholeheartedly.
(3)
Reply
(0)
SSG Land And Ammo Ncoic
SSG (Join to see)
10 y
Sir, after reviewing your profile, (fort Lewis peeked my interest) I'm upset, your gonna be leaving about a month or 2 before I get there, and I'd sure like to serve under a leader with your character... Now I'll wipe my nose and say, let's not forget about when the Red Sea was parted to allow passage of his followers and closed on the pursuing forces drowning them all but a few. And a verse from a hymn I recall spoken from the apostles "lord forgive them for they know not what they do"
(1)
Reply
(0)
COL Strategic Plans Chief
COL (Join to see)
10 y
SSG (Join to see), have fun at JBLM. I really wish I could stay, but I've been here over 4 years and the road is calling. Trust me. I'd rather be here. Heading to the Pentagon.
(1)
Reply
(0)
Avatar small

Join nearly 2 million former and current members of the US military, just like you.

close