20
20
0
I'm a SPC; well, my SRB says I am. The issues came to a SGT in my platoon who told me he had denied my advancement to SPC. he also said There was a computer error. I wasn't supposed to be SPC. also had me come back after lunch wearing PFC. I've asked for my counseling, stating I've been denied my advancement I've been told that I've been verbally counseled and to stop being a pain in the ass to my leadership. AR 600-8-19 mentioned nothing about verbal counseling, I talked to my 1SG and he was for having me promoted to SPC, I am clueless about what to do at this point.
Posted in these groups: 
Promotions
Regulation
Promotions Regulation
Posted >1 y ago
Responses: 25
Yea, your NCO can't stop it. Can recommend to stop, but that's it. Your Commander is the one that signs the 4187 to advance you to SPC. Your NCO is a dickbag. Have an Open Door with your 1SG and Commander and ask for a copy of the 4187 with Commanders approval with signature. If your NCO still has a problem with it, they can take it up with them.
(29)
(0)
PO2 John Harker
It will be in your service record when you're promoted, so go by that.
There is a certain amount of harassment with promotion, especially to E-4. It comes from both directions but will soon stop. Back when I was in the harassment was physical, though only with the promotee's consent.
The bigger issue is by hitting E-4, you are now expected to be a leader. You're expected to be in charge of small groups and support the mission with them. Some of your chain of command will be very vocal with their lack of support, I believe those people have already been identified as dickbags. It's not fair, no, but you will deal with those kinds of people from now throughout the rest of your life. You can try to have them corrected, you can ignore their stupid crap, or you can stand up to them. There's a time and place for each of the last two. I favor ignoring them unless it's something truly worth fighting over (like standing up for your troops, family, etc.) In that case, stand up to them and do not budge. It will be stressful and you may face corrective action, but it's the right choice so do not waver on it.
There is a certain amount of harassment with promotion, especially to E-4. It comes from both directions but will soon stop. Back when I was in the harassment was physical, though only with the promotee's consent.
The bigger issue is by hitting E-4, you are now expected to be a leader. You're expected to be in charge of small groups and support the mission with them. Some of your chain of command will be very vocal with their lack of support, I believe those people have already been identified as dickbags. It's not fair, no, but you will deal with those kinds of people from now throughout the rest of your life. You can try to have them corrected, you can ignore their stupid crap, or you can stand up to them. There's a time and place for each of the last two. I favor ignoring them unless it's something truly worth fighting over (like standing up for your troops, family, etc.) In that case, stand up to them and do not budge. It will be stressful and you may face corrective action, but it's the right choice so do not waver on it.
(5)
(0)
SSG Eric Blue
Everyone here said what needed to be said so far. So all that I will add is to be VERY careful in the future. If you weren't on your NCO's s-list already, you will be now because they're power-tripping and can't stand the fact that they can't stop you. So they will probably try to slow down your professional growth. Continue to do your best work, no matter what. PO2 John Harker already gave some great advice as well. Good luck, soldier.
(4)
(0)
This is wrong on many levels. It looks like you haven't been counseled monthly. Your commander can deny your advancement to SPC but if they did that you wouldn't have not been promoted. I would ask to speak to the 1SG. He should be able to navigate this. If the Army says you are a SPC and you are getting paid as a SPC then you are a SPC. Usually, you pin on a rank when your leadership pins you but it is not required. There is a chance that you were denied advancement but if you were then they should have counseled you.
(25)
(0)
10
10
0
Many others have given you the textbook. Your NCO can't stop your promotion. And yes, you should absolutely go through your CoC to talk to 1SG/Commander.
But.....
If you are getting paid, there is almost no difference whether you have PFC or SPC on your chest. Does the issue need to be cleared up? Yes. Is it worth pissing off your SGT who can make your life miserable in so many other little ways? Nope. Not at all. It appears your SGT is not above being a dick for no apparent reason. How much worse will he be when you give him a "reason?"
So, yes, get it cleared up. But don't push it. Make sure it isn't *you* telling that SGT to pound sand, it is 1SG/Commander. And make sure that you don't rub it in after.
But.....
If you are getting paid, there is almost no difference whether you have PFC or SPC on your chest. Does the issue need to be cleared up? Yes. Is it worth pissing off your SGT who can make your life miserable in so many other little ways? Nope. Not at all. It appears your SGT is not above being a dick for no apparent reason. How much worse will he be when you give him a "reason?"
So, yes, get it cleared up. But don't push it. Make sure it isn't *you* telling that SGT to pound sand, it is 1SG/Commander. And make sure that you don't rub it in after.
(10)
(0)
Read This Next
Continue with Facebook 
Continue with Google