Posted on Oct 27, 2014
Do you understand why mixing religion and politics may be the only thing that can save our country?
84.3K
813
602
22
15
7
Many people feel that the First Amendment calls for the separation of Church and State. No where in the Amendment do these words appear, but many people feel that is what our Founding Fathers had in mind when they wrote our Constitution. One of our Founding Fathers stated "Christians should vote for Christian Leaders" (paraphrased) and you can look it up to prove its validity. When I speak of mixing religion and politics I am speaking of the ethics and integrity of people who know they must answer to a Higher Power (I call Him God). We need people who know that the greatest among us must be the servant of all. The First Amendment prevents government from setting up a mandatory national religion and prevents the government from messing with each citizen's individual right to worship as he or she sees fit. Look it up and read it before you argue with me. I just want to know how you all would feel about having elected officials that were honest, had integrity, and lead our country with those qualities. I am also enclosing a copy of an article I found in our newspaper (which surprised me as they tend to be pretty liberal!)! I am eager to hear your responses. Let's pick up this topic and run with it! it would not let me post the Newspaper article, but it basically says we need to stand up for people who truly stand up for God.
Posted 10 y ago
Responses: 97
Well PO1 Steven Kuhn that is a excellent question and one that requires the exhaustive study for history especially in the 16th and 17th Centuries. Are you ready? OUTSTANDING!
First we really have to look at what the Protestant Reformation did to Europe and how it affected the regional Monarchs who ruled inside what today is Modern Germany but back then was call the Holy Roman Empire and was nominally ruled by Electors who were German Princes that elected the Emperor (Normally a Austrian Hapsburg). The reformation allowed these German Princes (for example the Hohenzollerns in Brandenburg) to renounce Catholicism thus cutting the power of the Hapsburg's and the Catholic Church out of their country's power structure, taking the wealth of the various monasteries and churches of the area and turning it into the personal wealth of the Monarch.
Now we come to Henry VIII, we all know the story of WHY he wanted to break with the Catholic Church (The Pope wanted to maintain influence with the Charles of Spain who was a Hapsburg and also Emperor of the HRE and so when Henry wanted to divorce Charles' sister the Pope denied it thus causing the rift) but, after Bloody Mary, Elizabeth I, The Glorious Revolution, the reinstallation of William III. This WHOLE time period people were fleeing like refugees and were indeed refugees trying to escape this mad Europe filled with ever changing religions, wars, and chaos so they came to the English Colonies.
The English Colonies had their own problems but you could worship and feel confident that some king wasn't going to change his religion (and thus yours!) to get a divorce, forge an alliance, or use your spiritual wellbeing as some coin that he could spend in the name of politics. That my friend is why we have a SEPARATION of Church and State, that is also why I will shed my blood to keep it that way.
As to your last statement. No politician having gained substantial power in a nation has ever done it through honesty and integrity. There is always blood somewhere and always lies to be found. If you believe otherwise I advise you to read some history on your own.
First we really have to look at what the Protestant Reformation did to Europe and how it affected the regional Monarchs who ruled inside what today is Modern Germany but back then was call the Holy Roman Empire and was nominally ruled by Electors who were German Princes that elected the Emperor (Normally a Austrian Hapsburg). The reformation allowed these German Princes (for example the Hohenzollerns in Brandenburg) to renounce Catholicism thus cutting the power of the Hapsburg's and the Catholic Church out of their country's power structure, taking the wealth of the various monasteries and churches of the area and turning it into the personal wealth of the Monarch.
Now we come to Henry VIII, we all know the story of WHY he wanted to break with the Catholic Church (The Pope wanted to maintain influence with the Charles of Spain who was a Hapsburg and also Emperor of the HRE and so when Henry wanted to divorce Charles' sister the Pope denied it thus causing the rift) but, after Bloody Mary, Elizabeth I, The Glorious Revolution, the reinstallation of William III. This WHOLE time period people were fleeing like refugees and were indeed refugees trying to escape this mad Europe filled with ever changing religions, wars, and chaos so they came to the English Colonies.
The English Colonies had their own problems but you could worship and feel confident that some king wasn't going to change his religion (and thus yours!) to get a divorce, forge an alliance, or use your spiritual wellbeing as some coin that he could spend in the name of politics. That my friend is why we have a SEPARATION of Church and State, that is also why I will shed my blood to keep it that way.
As to your last statement. No politician having gained substantial power in a nation has ever done it through honesty and integrity. There is always blood somewhere and always lies to be found. If you believe otherwise I advise you to read some history on your own.
(0)
(0)
Here is the Issue, everyone has different scales of morality. The group with "lower" moral's attack's the group with "higher" morals, because the ones with "higher" moral's tend to have some kind of divine belief, compared to those with "lower" moral's usually having a blatant hatred for divine belief, is indifferent toward divine belief, or is fair-weather in their divine belief. Naturally, those with the "lower moral's" will naturally attack those with the "higher" moral's by accusing them of imposing their religious belief's on those with "lower morals".
Should religious moral's be an element of our government? Thats a tough question, mostly because if you say No.... you are saying its alright to go around stealing, pillaging and raping... (As you remember, many of those thing's are forbidden in religion, as are they general crimes which have a victim, but saying No to ALL religious morality means even saying no to the things both sides agree upon for mutual safety) which is pretty much the complete absence of government. If you say yes, well then you pretty much have the Taliban Regime or some other extremist psuedo-theocracy. Ofcourse we looked at "Yes" and "No" being extreme absolutes, but I think you get the point that we need moderation.
Whomever is the majority culture (be it Athiests or Religious folks) should have an influence on the law's, that's the point of Democracy, the group with the most people get the most say, i.e. "Mob Rule"... Dont want to piss of the Majority of your country, they can cause a major inconvenience to your government .... but at the same time dont trample on the rights of those who don't believe in the same thing as you.
83% of American's are Christians (Acording to ABC http://abcnews.go.com/US/story?id=90356). Logically that shouldn't be confusing to you as to why there is Christian overtone within our government and in our history. If 83% of America believes in a certain faith, it would only make sense that the majority of individuals within our government would also have the same faith as the 83% of America.
Thats why we have religion in politic's, and why its a good thing.
Should religious moral's be an element of our government? Thats a tough question, mostly because if you say No.... you are saying its alright to go around stealing, pillaging and raping... (As you remember, many of those thing's are forbidden in religion, as are they general crimes which have a victim, but saying No to ALL religious morality means even saying no to the things both sides agree upon for mutual safety) which is pretty much the complete absence of government. If you say yes, well then you pretty much have the Taliban Regime or some other extremist psuedo-theocracy. Ofcourse we looked at "Yes" and "No" being extreme absolutes, but I think you get the point that we need moderation.
Whomever is the majority culture (be it Athiests or Religious folks) should have an influence on the law's, that's the point of Democracy, the group with the most people get the most say, i.e. "Mob Rule"... Dont want to piss of the Majority of your country, they can cause a major inconvenience to your government .... but at the same time dont trample on the rights of those who don't believe in the same thing as you.
83% of American's are Christians (Acording to ABC http://abcnews.go.com/US/story?id=90356). Logically that shouldn't be confusing to you as to why there is Christian overtone within our government and in our history. If 83% of America believes in a certain faith, it would only make sense that the majority of individuals within our government would also have the same faith as the 83% of America.
Thats why we have religion in politic's, and why its a good thing.
Poll: Most Americans Say They're Christian
Ask Americans their religion and you'll get an earful — 50 individual answers in an ABCNEWS/Beliefnet poll, ranging from agnostics to Zen Buddhists. The vast majority, though, have something in common: Jesus Christ.Eighty-three percent of Americans identify themselves as Christians. Most of the...
(1)
(1)
SGT Suraj Dave
PO3 Camille Romero,
Its not about who deep down is a child of God and who isn't, its about how the people identify themselv's. 83% claim they "follow" Christianity even if they only go to Church or Mass on Christmas and Easter. They are fair-weather Christians but that isnt the point.
One more thing about your post, which really bothered me... Just because you mess up sometimes (Have a kid out of wedlock, get trashed a lot, etc.. etc...) doesnt make you not a Christian. We all mess up, we all make mistakes. Its not our place to judge others on their life styles or church/mass attendance.
I love God a Lot, and I know God loves me. I mess up a lot, trust me. I drink too much sometimes, I bring girl's back sometimes, and I do things and get involved with people that a Good Christian shouldn't be involved with, but like everyone else, I am a work in progress. I try not a mess up, but when I do I say sorry.... and God forgives me, because He is full of compassion, slow to anger, and abounding in love. There is no sin great enough to make God not love you. God loves atheists too, He might not love what they believe in, but he loves them very much just as he loves you and I....
The trick is not to tell people they are sinner's and they are going to hell. Threatening people doesn't work, its proven by statistics. Thats why we dont see as many cancer' lung commercials to stop smoking, it is too extreme so the listener turns it off. The ad's whcih advertise the benifits to quit smoking generally do better then the commercials showing you the harm of continuing to smoke cigarettes. So with that said, Instead you tell people about How much God already loves them, and how He has an awesome plan for their life.... and I let them know that faith the Lord doesnt make you immune from bad situations and lifes letdown's, but faith in God means you are not going to go through it alone. Keep the conversations positive... and if you get cursed out or spat on, thats alright. There is no better blessing to get persecuted for Christ! And if it seems like no one is listening, dont be discouraged... The word only says its your job to plant the seed. God's got the rest on lock down.
Its not about who deep down is a child of God and who isn't, its about how the people identify themselv's. 83% claim they "follow" Christianity even if they only go to Church or Mass on Christmas and Easter. They are fair-weather Christians but that isnt the point.
One more thing about your post, which really bothered me... Just because you mess up sometimes (Have a kid out of wedlock, get trashed a lot, etc.. etc...) doesnt make you not a Christian. We all mess up, we all make mistakes. Its not our place to judge others on their life styles or church/mass attendance.
I love God a Lot, and I know God loves me. I mess up a lot, trust me. I drink too much sometimes, I bring girl's back sometimes, and I do things and get involved with people that a Good Christian shouldn't be involved with, but like everyone else, I am a work in progress. I try not a mess up, but when I do I say sorry.... and God forgives me, because He is full of compassion, slow to anger, and abounding in love. There is no sin great enough to make God not love you. God loves atheists too, He might not love what they believe in, but he loves them very much just as he loves you and I....
The trick is not to tell people they are sinner's and they are going to hell. Threatening people doesn't work, its proven by statistics. Thats why we dont see as many cancer' lung commercials to stop smoking, it is too extreme so the listener turns it off. The ad's whcih advertise the benifits to quit smoking generally do better then the commercials showing you the harm of continuing to smoke cigarettes. So with that said, Instead you tell people about How much God already loves them, and how He has an awesome plan for their life.... and I let them know that faith the Lord doesnt make you immune from bad situations and lifes letdown's, but faith in God means you are not going to go through it alone. Keep the conversations positive... and if you get cursed out or spat on, thats alright. There is no better blessing to get persecuted for Christ! And if it seems like no one is listening, dont be discouraged... The word only says its your job to plant the seed. God's got the rest on lock down.
(0)
(0)
PO3 Camille Romero
SGT Suraj Dave:
Let me see if I can explain myself in more detail so you can better identify with what I was trying to say (I do want to state beforehand, though, that I don't wish to get into a lengthy debate.).... I apologize if you were disturbed by my post. It is hard to fully explain one's self sometimes in text. I will try to do better. I want to say that I am guilty of many times not being as disciplined a Christian as I should be according to what the Bible says how a follower/believer in Christ should behave/live. I admit I do not attend church like I should, and many times lately I have been a slacker when it comes to reading Scripture. Yes, I do make mistakes also. "MISTAKES", I said. That does not mean continually living in sin by fornicating, committing adultery, taking the Lord's name in vain, stealing, lying, killing, selling drugs, etc. Making mistakes is one thing, sir, but continuing to live a life of a morally depraved person is totally another. Yes! I certainly believe the Lord God loves atheists and sinners and would that all come to repentance and receive everlasting life. This is Scriptural. However, that same God and Savior will also be sending people to everlasting hell and damnation; this is in the Word of God, as well. He even said that the path to destruction is wide, and many there are who would choose to walk it. You say you are "a work in progress", well, so am I; but to continue to live as though we are reprobates (not just making mistakes) will be unacceptable to the Lord. I didn't make it up; it's in His Word. ___Also, as kind as I think you are trying to be about telling me how to witness to others about the Lord and His goodness (I think we may have gotten a little off track of the subject here), I believe what God's Word says, how the Holy Spirit will give the utterance in wisdom and power. Other than this, I feel I should keep quiet.
Thank you for your time and service, Sgt! :)
Let me see if I can explain myself in more detail so you can better identify with what I was trying to say (I do want to state beforehand, though, that I don't wish to get into a lengthy debate.).... I apologize if you were disturbed by my post. It is hard to fully explain one's self sometimes in text. I will try to do better. I want to say that I am guilty of many times not being as disciplined a Christian as I should be according to what the Bible says how a follower/believer in Christ should behave/live. I admit I do not attend church like I should, and many times lately I have been a slacker when it comes to reading Scripture. Yes, I do make mistakes also. "MISTAKES", I said. That does not mean continually living in sin by fornicating, committing adultery, taking the Lord's name in vain, stealing, lying, killing, selling drugs, etc. Making mistakes is one thing, sir, but continuing to live a life of a morally depraved person is totally another. Yes! I certainly believe the Lord God loves atheists and sinners and would that all come to repentance and receive everlasting life. This is Scriptural. However, that same God and Savior will also be sending people to everlasting hell and damnation; this is in the Word of God, as well. He even said that the path to destruction is wide, and many there are who would choose to walk it. You say you are "a work in progress", well, so am I; but to continue to live as though we are reprobates (not just making mistakes) will be unacceptable to the Lord. I didn't make it up; it's in His Word. ___Also, as kind as I think you are trying to be about telling me how to witness to others about the Lord and His goodness (I think we may have gotten a little off track of the subject here), I believe what God's Word says, how the Holy Spirit will give the utterance in wisdom and power. Other than this, I feel I should keep quiet.
Thank you for your time and service, Sgt! :)
(0)
(0)
SGT Suraj Dave
Hey,
Just telling you what the statistics say. On my Big 10 Campus, I see preachers every day from every denomination tell the students they are going to hell. No one ever listen's. Every once in a while a preacher who shows up to tell the students no matter how gay or how crippled they are, God loves them, eventhough He doesnt love their choices. I have seen it work with my own eyes. (Also, I am a BBH major (BioBehavioral Health) and part of my degree is studying health advertisements and knowing what makes them effective/ineffective. Threatening people is always Ineffective, just saying that. Not trying to tell you how to witness.
Thank you also PO3 Camille Romero and good luck
Just telling you what the statistics say. On my Big 10 Campus, I see preachers every day from every denomination tell the students they are going to hell. No one ever listen's. Every once in a while a preacher who shows up to tell the students no matter how gay or how crippled they are, God loves them, eventhough He doesnt love their choices. I have seen it work with my own eyes. (Also, I am a BBH major (BioBehavioral Health) and part of my degree is studying health advertisements and knowing what makes them effective/ineffective. Threatening people is always Ineffective, just saying that. Not trying to tell you how to witness.
Thank you also PO3 Camille Romero and good luck
(0)
(0)
PO3 Camille Romero
SGT Suraj Dave:
While I appreciate your study of health advertisement, this is not quite the same as being empowered by the Lord Himself. While humanity may tell us one thing, the Scriptures say God's Word will not return to Him void, and also "with men it is impossible, but with God ALL things are possible". If the person witnessing is being used by God, the hearer will hear what the Holy Spirit wants him to hear; they can choose to accept or reject. ~~~ All the very best to you, Sgt!
While I appreciate your study of health advertisement, this is not quite the same as being empowered by the Lord Himself. While humanity may tell us one thing, the Scriptures say God's Word will not return to Him void, and also "with men it is impossible, but with God ALL things are possible". If the person witnessing is being used by God, the hearer will hear what the Holy Spirit wants him to hear; they can choose to accept or reject. ~~~ All the very best to you, Sgt!
(0)
(0)
This is so true. People with character make great leaders. But people of character can come from all walks of life. The freedom to convey ones opinions is a double sided dagger in that it demands you to also smell, look and listen for yourself. God bless America
(0)
(0)
PO1 Steven Kuhn
I agree with the double sided dagger. Many people have not been so much turned off by the idea of Christianity as much as Christians who say one thing and do another. We are all human, and we grow in our walk with Christ on a daily basis, never achieving perfection but trying to be more Christ like with each passing day. My worry is that we have been warned by our Founding Fathers that we cannot call ourselves true patriots if we try and take religion and morality out of the public arena (politics) [George Washington] and I another Founder said that a nation without a sense of morality (they were stating it from a religious perspective) cannot be lead/ruled.
r/
Steve
r/
Steve
(0)
(0)
Always a topic of contention! I believe I understand your thinking, PO1 Steven Kuhn, and I appreciate the position you take, but I can't help but wonder: doesn't that already happen? Don't some Christians already vote for Christian Leaders on their religious preference? If I wasn't a Christian, but running for office, I doubt I would get many votes from Christians. I obviously want leaders that are honest and have integrity, but if they aren't Christians (or at least don't mention whether they are or not) does that automatically make them lesser leaders? It is my firm belief that leaders work for their subordinates as much as those subordinates work for their leaders; the same should be true for elected officials, regardless of their religion or lack thereof. I feel as though if ONLY Christian leaders were elected into office, then eventually a theocracy would rule, though it certainly wouldn't happen overnight. And what would happen to those that don't want to follow Christianity, or have no religion at all? And don't get me wrong; the same could be said if only Atheists or other religions were elected into office. I feel that the best course of action is to continue to allow all eligible individuals, regardless of religious views/culture/gender, to run for elected office. It seems to me that this is the best way to encourage open-mindedness among leaders.
(0)
(0)
PO1 Steven Kuhn
Sir, again repectfully, we came from that and still allowed freedom of different religions. I believe that we need integrity and morality in our goverment leaders and society.
(0)
(0)
SFC (Join to see)
True. I'm just wondering if being Christian (or any other religion) automatically make one more virtuous and moral than someone who isn't. On the other hand, does being Atheist or agnostic automatically make one less virtuous and moral? I understand certain qualities make people more or less desirable at first glance, but people are deeper and more complex than their outward appearance and behavior might suggest.
(2)
(0)
While I identify with Christian values, always repeated the pledge of allegiance, always take my hat off and stand to the national anthem and put my hand over my heart. I am not a Christian. I do identify with protestants as the morals in the various gospels meaning is still relevant today. I do not believe that politics and religion are the cure for anything. Cultural shift back to a word, a word we used to use every day when I was growing up. A word which holds no meaning anymore. A word that you hear in military service, but very often doesn't have a great of impact as it should. A word that will be the rise or fall of our entire culture. A word that stands for an ideal of freedom and portrays meritocracy and reward for hard work and ownership. That word is Accountability. Our culture, our nation and the world have left that word behind 15 years ago.
(0)
(0)
PO1 Steven Kuhn
SGT Patrick McCullough I agree that accountability is very important. I also believe that morality and integrity walk hand in hand with accountability.
r/
Steve
r/
Steve
(0)
(0)
SGT Patrick McCullough
While I agree integrity and accountability are similar you can't have integrity without accountability. When it comes to morality your (mileage may vary) sense of morality might be different from Mine
(0)
(0)
Separation of Church and State is a good issue to discuss. First of all you have to look at it from the point of view of our forefathers. In their time the major political parties were also the religions or religious parties of the time. The church handled gathering of taxes and held courts much like our government does today. If a person was of a different religion of the individuals holding the court then they didn't stand much of a chance of winning their case. There was a need for courts and government to operate based solely on laws rather than on the whims of religious leaders. Our current system is based solely on laws agreed upon by the majority of parties interested. Separation of Church and state has nothing to do with taking God out of everything as is evident on the currency we use. "In God We Trust" I think it is important that individuals vote for people that best represent their religious values, social status, and that has the vision of America that they share. Many ultra liberals take the meaning way to far to the left and many ultra conservatives take it way too far to the right. People have a right to freedom of religion wherever they are in our country and some seem to forget that point. Just because teachers shouldn't be using their position as a pulpit to preach their religion to students, doesn't mean that we take God out of the schools, nor the ability of students to gather privately on their own time to study their religion, pray or discuss it among themselves. Students should be able to form religious clubs if they want for after school activities or for gatherings within the schools whenever schools allow time for clubs to meet. Keeping a separation of church and state in our government doesn't mean we take God out of everything either, a President should be able to express his religious views as long as it is during appropriate times, like memorial ceremonies, letting it be known where he attends church and what religious leaders he most admires. It is ok to pray for our country, God knows we really need it right now with all the division being preached at us from both sides. "Together we stand, divided we fall." America needs to come together on issues rather than remaining forever separated. This will take moderates from both major parties to achieve. Voting in ultra liberals or ultra conservatives will only further divide our country. We need legislators that can work together and that can compromise to achieve equitable legislation for all Americans, not just an elite few. Like I said earlier vote for those who best represent you and your needs, don't worry about everyone else. Everyone is so concerned about everyone else or losing what they think are rights that they forget that the issue really doesn't even affect them. Whatever your politics make sure and vote in every election because if you don't then you are truly sending the message that you really don't care what happens to your country. Keeping a separation of church and state is necessary because Christians may not always be in the majority. So pray and pray often because the nation really needs it.
(0)
(0)
PO1 Steven Kuhn
You make some excellent points, and I am glad to hear them. My position is that our nation was founded on Christian principles by Christian men. If anyone takes the time to read American History or the bibliography of our founding fathers, or President Washington's farewell address they will be able to discern the truth. I made this point because of the lack of morality of our three branches of government and our lack of leadership.
(0)
(0)
Read This Next