The True Importance of an Education While in the Military
All great points, I think the biggest thing I like to stress about education is what you mentioned, it shows discipline, moreso important a discipline to your craft that you would call a profession.
Being more marketable after you leave service is paramount! I think a lot of SM's forget that the Military and Civilian operational enviornment is completly opposite. This is the importance of getting an education it shows the future employer that you can adapt to a new tempo.
Wish that 1SG and CSM would civilian education a bigger part of their NCODP plans for their senior NCOs.
I think being 'educated' is important. The higher we move up on the enlisted side, we could be working along some Field Grades with multiple Master's Degrees. It is important to be able to "talk the same language" so to speak. But education is NOT everything and I do agree with you.
You can be 24 years old with a B.A. in Business Leadership but are you really ready to be a leader or manager of a business? Or would a 24 year old Sergeant that has a few years leading Soldiers and managing a team or squad would be better suited? I'd take the NCO with experience rather a college graduate with ZERO experience.
SFC Cornelius, in our maintenance realm, we cannot learn to be mechanic's through a classroom. We have to be out there troubleshooting and using the trial/error methods to fix or figure out the fault. Using a TM as a guide will assist in building experience, but that experience and knowledge comes from actually doing it.
Ok, I've rambled enough. Just my thoughts.
I fully understand your point, and it brings up the long time debate of "education" over "experience". I worked at a Ford Dealer during my time as a Weekend Soldier, and I have to say that in our realm (Maintenance) no topic is more talked about than this one.
I personally am Certified as both a Ford Master Drive Tech, and an ASE Master Tech. I have to tell you that the civilian diagnosis is completly different from the Military diagnostic process. But as a professional technician you need education for both customer satisfaction and experiance (provided it is a hands-on education), one is not greater than the other. Customers want to see certifications hanging on the wall, and want to see you fix it right. Again education and experience compliment one another. This outlook is my opinion.