Posted on May 29, 2015
"Iraq exists only as an idea, not a nation." What do you think of the author's assertion?
2.18K
10
8
2
2
0
Defense Secretary Ashton Carter did misspeak last week with remarks that caused a firestorm in both Washington and Baghdad. He explained the Islamic State’s takeover of Ramadi by saying Iraqi forces “showed no will to fight.” He just forgot to complete the sentence by adding the words, “for Iraq.”
It’s clear that many people are willing to fight fiercely and bravely in that part of the world — just look at the levels of violence. The Kurds fight ferociously for Kurdistan. The Shiites have been fighting doggedly for their people. The Sunnis of the Islamic State are killing and dying for their cause. But nobody is willing to fight for Iraq. The problem really is not that Iraq’s army has collapsed. It’s that Iraq has collapsed.
http://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/iraq-exists-only-as-an-idea-not-a-nation/2015/05/28/5d9e37c8-0577-11e5-bc72-f3e16bf50bb6_story.html
It’s clear that many people are willing to fight fiercely and bravely in that part of the world — just look at the levels of violence. The Kurds fight ferociously for Kurdistan. The Shiites have been fighting doggedly for their people. The Sunnis of the Islamic State are killing and dying for their cause. But nobody is willing to fight for Iraq. The problem really is not that Iraq’s army has collapsed. It’s that Iraq has collapsed.
http://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/iraq-exists-only-as-an-idea-not-a-nation/2015/05/28/5d9e37c8-0577-11e5-bc72-f3e16bf50bb6_story.html
Edited >1 y ago
Posted >1 y ago
Responses: 6
Yup ... dead on.
Iraq never really existed until 11 November 1920.
The British established the "State of Iraq" under the Hashemite king, Faisal I of Iraq, who had been forced out of Syria by the French.
British authorities selected Sunni Arab elites from the region for appointments to government and ministry offices.
Iraq is approximately 60-70 percent Arab Shi'a, 20-30 percent Arab Sunni and 10 percent Kurdish.
Iraqi Kurds are mostly Sunni, with about 10% being Shi'a Faili Kurds.
So from the get-go the west had enforced a minority rule of the area.
What could go wrong?
Iraq never really existed until 11 November 1920.
The British established the "State of Iraq" under the Hashemite king, Faisal I of Iraq, who had been forced out of Syria by the French.
British authorities selected Sunni Arab elites from the region for appointments to government and ministry offices.
Iraq is approximately 60-70 percent Arab Shi'a, 20-30 percent Arab Sunni and 10 percent Kurdish.
Iraqi Kurds are mostly Sunni, with about 10% being Shi'a Faili Kurds.
So from the get-go the west had enforced a minority rule of the area.
What could go wrong?
(1)
(0)
There are three nations inside the 'border' of Iraq. This was done intentionally by the Brits in Iraq and Afghanistan when carving up the old Ottoman Empire, but other also by Imperial Powers elsewhere. When occupying a foreign land its best to keep factions fighting one another so as to not fight the Empire. Find a roughly 1/3 minority, raise them to power to control the government, military and structures of power, make them dependent on you and they become fierce fighters to perpetuate the status quo against the other 2/3s. This all works until there is no Imperial Power to support that 1/3, or until you decide the strongman that inherited that 1/3 after the Empire needs his regime changed. Then the inherent imbalance in the 'country' you drew will eventually re-stabilize through war: it will either split along ideological lines into several sub-nations, or one group will rise to dominate the others (often brutally). ISIS/ISIL/Daesh knows their history, we seem to have overlooked it.
https://www.google.com/search?q=Sykes%E2%80%93Picot+ISIS+ISIL&ie=utf-8&oe=utf-8
https://www.google.com/search?q=Sykes%E2%80%93Picot+ISIS+ISIL&ie=utf-8&oe=utf-8
(1)
(0)
This is some of the truest things I have ever heard about Iraq. I think it is dead on.
(1)
(0)
Read This Next