NCOER question - handling a superbly physically fit NCO with a profile

EDIT: Everyone, I KNOW what goes in the section of the APFT. I know what it says and I know that there are other things that pertain to that section besides the APFT. However, in MY experiences, people don't give a crap about anything that isn't APFT. Non-APFT stuff in that block is usually fluff, whether that's the way it's supposed to be or not. What I am looking for are SAMPLE BULLETS of an excellence that isn't based off an APFT score.

I am about to get my first profile really and certainly my first perm profile. At least until I receive my disc surgery in my back, I won't be able to run or do high impact things, or do situps.

However, I think it's unfair that people say "well 270+ = excellence". Because while it hurts like crazy on my back I can smoke most people that score that high.

I squat and deadlift about 405lbs, and bench about 315lbs. I am about 15% under body fat and you can see an eight pack of abs, and they're not skinny abs.

I say all that not to brag or seem full of myself but rather to ask - I know I am in better shape and clearly more physically fit than a ton of people I know that score 90 in each event. Yet I have no chance at ever having an excellence again?

What bullets have you seen to quantify an excellence when someone is on profile?