Posted on Dec 22, 2014
1SG(P) 1st Sergeant
29.3K
41
31
5
5
0
What is one thing you would change about the military if you could?
Posted in these groups: Tumblr static tumblr mtb09amgp11s0247uo1 1280 Military Life
Avatar feed
Responses: 17
Capt Richard I P.
8
8
0
Edited 10 y ago
I would change personnel management, make it more like the private sector.

EDIT: Based on the confusion generated by my initial comment pointed out by Cpl Dennis F., i would change the command-economy model of personnel management in the military in favor for a free market, like the civilian sector. I would empower commanders (at as low a level as possible) to manage their budgets and hire and fire- at least for billets and assignments, if not for the service itself.

Example: Lt Terrible is incompetent as a platoon commander. His Battalion Commander fires him and he goes into a generalized waiting pool where he applies for other jobs that a 2ndLt of his specialty can fill e.g. Div Intel Officer he eventually has to accept as less desirable position, or lower prestige, or maybe even lower pay. Conversely, Captain Awesome wants to stay a platoon commander, even though he's now a Captain. He is willing to accept a smaller paycheck and tells his Battalion commander this, and is allowed to keep doing the work he loves.

The article linked below fleshes out in great detail the theory that good, high performing members of the military depart mostly because they don't get to keep doing what they want, largely due to a lock step method of personnel management and development over which they, and their commanders, have virtually no control. The article was later parlayed into a book, also linked.

http://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2011/01/why-our-best-officers-are-leaving/308346/

http://www.amazon.com/Bleeding-Talent-Military-Mismanages-Revolution/dp/ [login to see]
(8)
Comment
(0)
Cpl Dennis F.
Cpl Dennis F.
10 y
Thanks for the clarification Capt.
(1)
Reply
(0)
SSgt Carpenter
SSgt (Join to see)
10 y
Capt Richard I P. Excellent article sir. One of the reasons that even if I qualified to become an officer, I'd have no interest. As an enlistedman, I have much more say in my career, and I enjoy being a soldier. I don't have much interest in driving a desk.
(2)
Reply
(0)
Capt Richard I P.
Capt Richard I P.
10 y
SSgt (Join to see) Glad you enjoyed it. We need good people at all ranks, and more freedom and involvement in one's employment is rarely a bad thing.
(0)
Reply
(0)
SSG Security Officer
SSG (Join to see)
10 y
Thanks for the clarification sir
(1)
Reply
(0)
Avatar small
SSG Aircraft Mechanic
5
5
0
The fact that it has become a social experiment.
(5)
Comment
(0)
MAJ Senior Observer   Controller/Trainer
MAJ (Join to see)
>1 y
SSG (Join to see), you beat me to the punch! Absolutely! Ditch Political Correctness and the false notion that all things can be equitable and "fair" across the board. Combat is not now, nor has it ever been an equal employment opportunity. When we say PC, we should be referring to a patrol cap, and nothing more!
(2)
Reply
(0)
Avatar small
SGT Supply Sergeant (S4)
3
3
0
TIS and TIG. There should be a way to "test" to the next pay grade. If I come into the Army at the ripe age of 32, I should be afforded the chance to test into a rank more appropriate for a man my age and knowledge. Instead, you have these 20 year old "Srg" who have no life experience, telling me how the best way to do something. If you try to help them and point out where they could do it better, they say," I'm the boss, I know better". The army could use people who have life experience so much better than the way they do.
(3)
Comment
(0)
MSgt Superintendent
MSgt (Join to see)
>1 y
In the Air Force, I see older Airmen advancing and getting promoted more quickly vs their younger counterparts quite often. They prioritize better and take better advantage of leadership opportunities, college courses and earning achievements. When it comes time to test for E-5, it basically boils down to performance reports and how effectively you studied for the test. Younger Airmen are often more concerned with their XBOX or how to abuse their liver.
(0)
Reply
(0)
SFC Platoon Sergeant
SFC (Join to see)
>1 y
If only the Army worked like this....i'll be 30 next month, been in the Army for almost 8 years and I'm pretty much stuck at CPL(P), which is why I'm reclassing after I get back from my current deployment....younger guys I've been in longer than have already reached SSG and its not only disheartening, but also a morale killer when I know I should be at that same level. I understand that its always gonna be a numbers game, which is why I haven't been promoted yet (Thanks Siganl Branch....), but now I have to step out of my comfort level, and a job I love, to get where I want to be....
(0)
Reply
(0)
Avatar small

Join nearly 2 million former and current members of the US military, just like you.

close