search
Log In
Sign Up
About Us
Business
Posted on Jul 12, 2018
If you are given an illegal order, e.g. to execute civilians, what should your course of action be? Immediate and Post?
SSG
(Join to see)
3.47K
37
22
6
6
0
Posted in these groups:
Orders
Law
Posted >1 y ago
Respond
Responses: 18
Sort By
Newest
Oldest
Votes
9
9
0
Sgt
Wayne Wood
Posted >1 y ago
Refuse. Period.
Vote up
(9)
Comment
Vote down
(0)
Comment
5
5
0
SGT
David A. 'Cowboy' Groth
Posted >1 y ago
I would flat out refuse, this isn't Nazi Germany or Communist China or Russia.
Vote up
(5)
Comment
Vote down
(0)
SGT
Christopher Hayden
>1 y
Or the US in My Lai or No Gun Ri...
Up
(2)
Reply
Down
(0)
SGT
David A. 'Cowboy' Groth
>1 y
SGT Christopher Hayden
- very true comparisons.
Up
(2)
Reply
Down
(0)
Comment
4
4
0
Sgt
(Join to see)
Edited >1 y ago
Posted >1 y ago
Why the question? Have you been given an order that you think is illegal?
Vote up
(4)
Comment
Vote down
(0)
Comment
Show More Comments
Read This Next
Hypothetical Executive Illegal Order
17 Votes
17 Comments
Do civilians really 'bother' you? (Post military)
69 Votes
44 Comments
Do you think this is an appropriate action for civilians to take upon themselves to pr...?
119 Votes
34 Comments
Can you clear post in civilians?
9 Votes
7 Comments
Curious what benefits you may be missing?
7 Votes
1 Comments
Sponsored Ad
Would you obey an illegal or unconstitutional order?
1.33K Votes
616 Comments
RallyPoint Home
Join nearly 2 million former and current members of the US military, just like you.
Log In
Sign Up
close
Scroll
close
Sign Up with Facebook
Sign Up with Google
OR
Sign Up with Email
Already have an account?
Log In
Log In with Facebook
Log In with Google
OR
Please enter an email address
Please enter a password
Forgot your password?
Log In with Email
Don’t have an account?
Sign Up
Welcome to RallyPoint!
Continue with Facebook
Continue with Google
Continue with Facebook
Continue with Google
Military Affiliation
*
Active Duty
Active Reserve / National Guard
Pre-Commission
Veteran / Retired
Civilian Supporter
Branch
*
Air Force
Army
Coast Guard
Marine Corps
Navy
Space Force
Air Force Reserve
Air National Guard
Army National Guard
Army Reserve
Coast Guard Reserve
Marine Corps Reserve
Navy Reserve
Air Force ROTC
Army ROTC
Navy ROTC
USAFA
USMA
USNA
Civilian
Rank
*
Military Speciality
*
First Name
*
Last Name
*
Civilian Email
*
Password
*
Let's Go!
Your role
*
Military Family
DoD Civilian
US Government (non-DoD) civilian
Civilian Recruiter
Civilian Supporter
Potential Recruit
Spouse
Caregiver
Survivor
First Name
*
Last Name
*
Email
*
Password
*
Let's Go!