Posted on Nov 4, 2014
I just came across the article in military.com...The professor is crazy for saying this, what do you say as Leaders?
1.39K
1
8
0
0
0
Professor Claims US Military 'Greater Threat' to Peace Than ISIS
fighters from ISIL
Nov 04, 2014
Fox News
An Arizona college professor charged that American soldiers are anti-Muslim rapists who pose "a greater threat" to world peace than ISIS, and says he leveled the charge to make the U.S. "stronger and better."
University of Arizona instructor Musa al-Gharbi, who also is an academic affiliate at the university's Southwest Initiative for the Study of Middle East Conflicts, made the comments in a column penned for the online forum TruthOut, and defended them when reached by The Washington Free Beacon. He called Americans "hypocritical" for expressing moral outrage at the Islamic State, which has raped, murdered and beheaded thousands of Muslims and Christians in its quest to establish a Muslim caliphate in Syria and Iraq.
"It would not be a stretch to say that the United States is actually a greater threat to peace and stability in the region than ISIS — not least because U.S. policies in Iraq, Libya and Syria have largely paved the way for ISIS' emergence as a major regional actor," al-Gharbi wrote in the article titled, "How Much Moral High Ground Does the U.S. Have Over ISIS?"
Al-Gharbi claimed that the isolated instances of U.S. soldiers committing atrocities including rape, for which they face court-martial and imprisonment if found guilty, are on a level with the widespread and systematic brutality of Islamic State radicals.
"Many of the same behaviors condemned by the Obama administration and used to justify its most recent campaign into Iraq and Syria are commonly perpetrated by U.S. troops and are ubiquitous in the broader American society," al-Gharbi wrote. "U.S. soldiers and contractors have and continue to torture their enemies, often taking obscene photos to brag about and reminisce upon their acts."
Al-Gharbi also claimed that the U.S. military has been "heavily infiltrated by white supremacists, neo-Nazis, and other hate groups."
Al-Gharbi has written previously for Al Jazeera, including a column in July blaming Israel for provoking Hamas into firing rockets into Israel so it could invade Gaza.
The University of Arizona's Southwest Initiative for the Study of Middle East Conflicts distanced itself from al-Gharbi's writings in an email to the Free Beacon.
"SISMEC is a consortium of researchers, instructors and intellectuals who work both collaboratively and independently on critical issues related to the MENA region," a spokesman said. "We stand behind all work published on the SISMEC website, to include the research of al-Gharbi. However, those works published externally represent the views of the author and do not represent the initiative."
Robert Spencer, author of "Stealth Jihad: How Radical Islam is Subverting America without Guns or Bombs," said al-Gharbi's views are shared on campuses around the country.
"Musa al-Gharbi is not singular," Spencer wrote on the site JihadWatch.org. "There are professors all over the country who say essentially the same things."
Al-Gharbi, whose column acknowledges the rather obvious point that Islamic State poses a threat to the Syrian and Iraqi governments, claims the Obama administration's strategy for fighting the Islamic State will empower the terrorist army and "undermine the security and interests of the United States and its allies." He told the Free Beacon his controversial article was intended to improve U.S. policy.
"The goal of all of my work is to render U.S. policy more effective, efficient, and beneficent," Al-Gharbi told the newspaper by email. "I do this work out of my commitment to challenge America to grow better and stronger."
© Copyright 2014 Fox News. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.
fighters from ISIL
Nov 04, 2014
Fox News
An Arizona college professor charged that American soldiers are anti-Muslim rapists who pose "a greater threat" to world peace than ISIS, and says he leveled the charge to make the U.S. "stronger and better."
University of Arizona instructor Musa al-Gharbi, who also is an academic affiliate at the university's Southwest Initiative for the Study of Middle East Conflicts, made the comments in a column penned for the online forum TruthOut, and defended them when reached by The Washington Free Beacon. He called Americans "hypocritical" for expressing moral outrage at the Islamic State, which has raped, murdered and beheaded thousands of Muslims and Christians in its quest to establish a Muslim caliphate in Syria and Iraq.
"It would not be a stretch to say that the United States is actually a greater threat to peace and stability in the region than ISIS — not least because U.S. policies in Iraq, Libya and Syria have largely paved the way for ISIS' emergence as a major regional actor," al-Gharbi wrote in the article titled, "How Much Moral High Ground Does the U.S. Have Over ISIS?"
Al-Gharbi claimed that the isolated instances of U.S. soldiers committing atrocities including rape, for which they face court-martial and imprisonment if found guilty, are on a level with the widespread and systematic brutality of Islamic State radicals.
"Many of the same behaviors condemned by the Obama administration and used to justify its most recent campaign into Iraq and Syria are commonly perpetrated by U.S. troops and are ubiquitous in the broader American society," al-Gharbi wrote. "U.S. soldiers and contractors have and continue to torture their enemies, often taking obscene photos to brag about and reminisce upon their acts."
Al-Gharbi also claimed that the U.S. military has been "heavily infiltrated by white supremacists, neo-Nazis, and other hate groups."
Al-Gharbi has written previously for Al Jazeera, including a column in July blaming Israel for provoking Hamas into firing rockets into Israel so it could invade Gaza.
The University of Arizona's Southwest Initiative for the Study of Middle East Conflicts distanced itself from al-Gharbi's writings in an email to the Free Beacon.
"SISMEC is a consortium of researchers, instructors and intellectuals who work both collaboratively and independently on critical issues related to the MENA region," a spokesman said. "We stand behind all work published on the SISMEC website, to include the research of al-Gharbi. However, those works published externally represent the views of the author and do not represent the initiative."
Robert Spencer, author of "Stealth Jihad: How Radical Islam is Subverting America without Guns or Bombs," said al-Gharbi's views are shared on campuses around the country.
"Musa al-Gharbi is not singular," Spencer wrote on the site JihadWatch.org. "There are professors all over the country who say essentially the same things."
Al-Gharbi, whose column acknowledges the rather obvious point that Islamic State poses a threat to the Syrian and Iraqi governments, claims the Obama administration's strategy for fighting the Islamic State will empower the terrorist army and "undermine the security and interests of the United States and its allies." He told the Free Beacon his controversial article was intended to improve U.S. policy.
"The goal of all of my work is to render U.S. policy more effective, efficient, and beneficent," Al-Gharbi told the newspaper by email. "I do this work out of my commitment to challenge America to grow better and stronger."
© Copyright 2014 Fox News. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.
Posted 10 y ago
Responses: 3
Some professors that teach at university's have never been in the military and only go by what the media and Government say. maybe we should put them on the front line to get the feel of what we in the military go through each and everyday, while on active duty/ national guard/ or reserve and after we leave the service. I have a professor right now who has just given me a final grade for my last course of (F) in Homeland security and I am due to Graduate Friday Oct 27,2017. I did a couple research papers on terrorist attacks here in the states I left no stone un-turned i searched all news videos the day of the attacks, police logs, dispatch logs, witness statements and they did not add up to what the government and media had to say about it. He told me I was against the government and started giving me lower grades, has anyone else been through the same thing?
(0)
(0)
Already had this discussion in another thread.
https://www.rallypoint.com/answers/twisted-ivy-harvard-students-say-us-bigger-threat-to-world-peace-than-isis
And to be up front and honest, I agree with the professor's conclusion even if not his reasons.
https://www.rallypoint.com/answers/twisted-ivy-harvard-students-say-us-bigger-threat-to-world-peace-than-isis
And to be up front and honest, I agree with the professor's conclusion even if not his reasons.
Twisted Ivy: Harvard students say US bigger threat to world peace than ISIS | RallyPoint
Do you agree or disagree? http://www.foxnews.com/us/2014/10/08/twisted-ivy-harvard-students-say-us-bigger-threat-to-world-peace-than-isis/
(0)
(0)
CW2 Joseph Evans
We all got different reasons for thinking one group or another is a bigger threat. Some of the legit, some pure propaganda. My argument is, is that ISIS wouldn't exist if we hadn't funded them in Syria... So everything they do is sort of our fault... Then resupplying them with airdrops meant for the Kurds... Ooops.
(0)
(0)
SFC A.M. Drake
Ssgt Olsen,
Please give us more meat on what you mean about being sick. (However we all know you wanted the points
Please give us more meat on what you mean about being sick. (However we all know you wanted the points
(0)
(0)
SSgt (Join to see)
SFC Drake, I am so tired of this kind of thing. Most Americans are more conversative than others would have you to believe. For example I asked a former Air Force NCO why he was reading a GW Bush book and he told me he worked for him and he was very nice. He also said he has his own mind and will not let America haters to ruin our world.
(0)
(0)
Read This Next