Posted on Aug 11, 2017
SGT Joseph Gunderson
4.62K
9
12
2
2
0
621fa25e
Thinking about every movie that you have seen that portrayed any kind of military member. Do you believe that we are portrayed poorly, inaccurately, or perhaps in an almost negligent manner? Are certain aspects of our jobs, lives, or personalities made into more of caricatures of us?
Posted in these groups: Warnerbrotherslogo FilmTv logo TVTumblr static tumblr mtb09amgp11s0247uo1 1280 Military Life
Avatar feed
Responses: 9
CPO Glenn Moss
1
1
0
Service members and veterans are portrayed by actors in accordance with the script and the director's wishes.

No more, no less.

Even movies people love because they're supposedly "historically accurate" are following the whims of the script writers and the director.

Sometimes service members and veterans are portrayed accurately and well, other times less so.

People who want to know how things "really are" need to put the research time in to discover where the line dividing reality and fantasy/entertainment lies.
(1)
Comment
(0)
Avatar small
SGT Tony Clifford
1
1
0
The problem is that the people who make the movies have no real understanding of what soldiers are and how they interact. You'll either get the ultra progressive assumption that all soldiers are callous unthinking robots who only live to kill, or you get the ultra conservative perception of us being stoic heroes who only make choices to benefit the country. Oddly enough the comedies involving the military are really the closest be even those are exaggerations of how we act. The film industry plays to their audience, which either sees us as villains or god like heroes. It's understandable most Americans have never served and it's hard to explain military life to the uninitiated, so they just don't. This leads to a great divide in our society approaching a caste system.
(1)
Comment
(0)
SGT Michael Olsen
SGT Michael Olsen
7 y
Thats why I am writing "UNSUNG: The Forgotten". The first Drama/war film written by a soldier about soldiers.
(0)
Reply
(0)
Avatar small
SGT David T.
1
1
0
In some cases perhaps. Most of what I see is a glorification more than anything else.
(1)
Comment
(0)
Avatar small

Join nearly 2 million former and current members of the US military, just like you.

close