Posted on Jun 2, 2017
Should there be laws that make it illegal to impersonate a Veteran while panhandling to obtain money on the street?
2.93K
14
19
4
4
0
Posted >1 y ago
Responses: 8
Personally I think all panhandling should be illegal if it isn't already. I am a very charitable person and always willing to help someone down on their luck, but more and more people are taking advantage of the quick cash that I am now less inclined to help someone.
For instance, my mother saw an old man holding a sign claiming to be a homeless vet. She went home, grabbed a spare blanket, stopped at McDonald's and bought a couple value meals, and then gave the man those plus a couple singles she keeps in her wallet just in case. The guy threw the blanket and food on the ground, took the money, then spit on my mother for "not having more". A couple weeks later, she saw the same old man coming out of an apartment building. Not as homeless as he claimed.
Another instance, I've seen the same woman holding up various signs from "homeless, need help" to "Stranded, need money for a ride home". She hung out near the local Walmart to elicit pity money from the shoppers. Saw her there for a few weeks. Eventually she even brought a little dog into her game because who can't resist a puppy. Whether it was hers or not I'll never know. But too many people are out there preying off of the charity of others and it steals from those who actually do need that charity.
For instance, my mother saw an old man holding a sign claiming to be a homeless vet. She went home, grabbed a spare blanket, stopped at McDonald's and bought a couple value meals, and then gave the man those plus a couple singles she keeps in her wallet just in case. The guy threw the blanket and food on the ground, took the money, then spit on my mother for "not having more". A couple weeks later, she saw the same old man coming out of an apartment building. Not as homeless as he claimed.
Another instance, I've seen the same woman holding up various signs from "homeless, need help" to "Stranded, need money for a ride home". She hung out near the local Walmart to elicit pity money from the shoppers. Saw her there for a few weeks. Eventually she even brought a little dog into her game because who can't resist a puppy. Whether it was hers or not I'll never know. But too many people are out there preying off of the charity of others and it steals from those who actually do need that charity.
(3)
(0)
SMSgt Lawrence McCarter
I would agree it is 100% wrong but it seems in current times unlawful behavior and deception of this sort is not only not dealt with but excused. No matter how You look at it the impersonation of a veteran is to defraud.
(0)
(0)
CPO Robert (Mac) McGovern No, such a law would just add more work for the cops on the beat, and not actually resolve any issues - might just be an overnight in the local hoosegow for the panhandler. Most panhandlers would just ignore the law anyway.
(1)
(0)
CPO Robert (Mac) McGovern
Jim, I work for a local hospital and have secured $1000.00 from an individual who was hopsitalized. He had a sign that said he was a vet. He is not. This is common practice and is increasing nationally. If I cannot impersonate a police officer, I should not be able to impersonate a Veterans. Our civil liberties are being eroded because we elect to turn a blind eye using excuses to not have to address the issue. I appreciate your comment and believe in most instances you are right, it just should not make it right.
(0)
(0)
SP5 (Join to see)
I agree that the misrepresentation on the part of the impersonator is dead wrong. Passing a law to de-legitimize the action probably won't stop the action in most cases. I can see how dealing with the moocher at first hand as you do can reasonably cause you to be upset. Hope part of the $1000 went to pay for some of the hospital care.
(0)
(0)
Read This Next