Posted on Jul 31, 2016
Why is it so important for retired leaders to stay out of politics?
14.5K
184
104
9
9
0
With the recent bold public statements by retired generals in support of political candidates, I think it is good to discuss why this is a bad idea. They should know better. But I'm interested in why more junior folks think it is wrong, or perhaps why they think it's ok.
Posted >1 y ago
Responses: 70
Suspended Profile
I'm very curious to hear why you think it's a bad idea sir? History is full of retired GOs in politics, they understand the DIME better from living it that most of the career politicians and aren't we often complaining that there aren't more military people in political positions? This is point in our history where we have the fewest military people in congress and the senate. I think they have a lot to offer and even when I disagree with their point of view, it's easier for me to respect it because they've served.
I think they have as much right as anyone to express their beliefs. They are private citizens now.
(17)
(0)
Suspended Profile
Maj John Bell - (JOKE ALERT) personally, I really like pols, stats and sound bites that confirm my bias. It's just easier that way.
I am not junior, served 1977 to 1986, and I think the exact opposite of you. Citizenship is not a box where you make a check mark. I served, I am done. America needs an engaged citizenry, and professional soldiers offer a view and experience found nowhere else in the society. So, you and I disagree. On a personal note, my service ..my decision to be an officer revolved around a belief in America as a nation doing God's Will. If that nation, as it is now, is not doing God's Will, rejecting the Providential view of life...I would not serve, and would not recommend anyone to serve. To serve a state blindly is what the Germans did, and so many others.
(9)
(0)
Read This Next
Unfortunately actors and actresses like Eve Longoria or a Sean Penn are propped up on the same soapbox as if they had the same credibility. History has shown actors and generals are NOT contemporaries.