Posted on Apr 26, 2014
Do you salute a senior officer when walking alongside an even more senior officer?
136K
353
174
11
11
0
So I have been told different things and been told it is not in the regulations (and I also checked this out myself). If you are walking with an officer and an officer of the same rank as of the officer that you are walking with approaches do you salute them? Example: You are a CPT walking with a LTC and another LTC walks by do you salute?
I have heard it is respectful to salute and they just return your salute and you are on your way. I also heard that if you salute then you are disrespecting the officer that you are walking with.
And to take it one step further. You are a SGT walking with a COL and a CPT walks by do you salute the CPT?
I have heard it is respectful to salute and they just return your salute and you are on your way. I also heard that if you salute then you are disrespecting the officer that you are walking with.
And to take it one step further. You are a SGT walking with a COL and a CPT walks by do you salute the CPT?
Posted >1 y ago
Responses: 67
Semantics.... when in doubt, whip it out (solely referring to the salute... and the greeting of the day).
(33)
(0)
Col Dave Dales
I have saluted cars w placards knowing there is no way in the world they could see me. When in doubt.....
(2)
(0)
SP5 Joel O'Brien
Some time ago, I saluted the then Vice-President. Are we supposed to salute the Veep?
(1)
(0)
A1C Medrick "Rick" DeVaney
SP5 Joel O'Brien - .....
Always Salute A Superior Officer.
And That Includes Most Of The Park's Squirrels,
Always Salute A Superior Officer.
And That Includes Most Of The Park's Squirrels,
(0)
(0)
A SPC, 2LT, and CPT are walking together as they approach a SFC, CPT, and LTC. Who salutes who? I'm assuming it's like dividing by 0, where a black hole just engulfs everyone as soon as they walk within 6 paces of each other LOL
(25)
(0)
MAJ (Join to see)
"When in doubt, whip it out." How about this though: each group is led by a LTC, each has a CPT, a 2LT, and an SFC... Pass each other with a cancelation non-salute assumption, or all salute by 2s with the two SFCs left in a held - salute until the rest are done or gone?
(0)
(0)
CPT William Jones
Again everybody. If a higher rank officer approaches you salute. When an approaching service member salutes you it is returned by you so everybody salutes.
(0)
(0)
MSG Thomas Currie
Nothing complicated about the example you chose:
The SPC, 2LT and CPT _all_ simultaneously salute the LTC.
The LTC returns their salutes.
The CPT with the LTC exchanges salutes with the other CPT at the same time that the LTC is returning the salutes
The SFC salutes the CPT and 2LT at the same time that the LTC is returning the salutes.
The SPC, 2LT and CPT _all_ simultaneously salute the LTC.
The LTC returns their salutes.
The CPT with the LTC exchanges salutes with the other CPT at the same time that the LTC is returning the salutes
The SFC salutes the CPT and 2LT at the same time that the LTC is returning the salutes.
(0)
(0)
A1C Medrick "Rick" DeVaney
I Believe The ONE SOLUTE Per Day Rule, Only Applies To Warrant Officers...
~~~ I THINK. ~~ And For Me, Thinking Is A Rarity,
~~~ I THINK. ~~ And For Me, Thinking Is A Rarity,
(0)
(0)
Unless you are in a formal formation, where the formation leader represents the others, then everybody ought to still follow individual customs and courtesies. It doesn't matter who you happen to walk next to, behind, or in front of.
(21)
(0)
COL Ted Mc
LTC Yinon Weiss & MAJ Bryan Zeski - Gentlemen; I suspect that you are both correct(ish).
The way that I'd call it is "If you are WITH another person then the senior of the group is the only one who counts and the GROUPS salute as per the relationships between the senior members and it is the senior members who salute for the GROUPS. However if you are only with another person then you are a group of individuals and have to follow the code as individuals."
Face it, if you are a group led by a Lieutenant that is marching past the Camp Commandant and the Camp Sergeant Major then it is only the person in charge who salutes and it is only the Camp Commandant who returns the salute. (It would be highly improper for the Lieutenant to salute the Camp Sergeant Major and s/he would have to complete their salute to the Camp Commandant BEFORE they could return the salute of the Camp Sergeant Major [who would have to wait for the Camp Commandant to return the Lieutenant's salute before s/he saluted the Lieutenant as it would be highly improper for them to return a salute directed at the Camp Commandant].)
If you had two groups with Group 1 composed of an E-1, E-3, E-5, E-7, E-9, P-2, O-4, and an 0-6 and Group 2 composed of an E-2, E-4, E-6, E-8, O-1, O-3, O-5, and an O-7 and if each pair of salutes took 30 seconds to complete, you would spend almost an hour (56 minutes to be exact) just getting the "meeting" portions of the salutes done AND, since you would (obviously) have had to stand still to get those salutes done then you would have to spend the same length of time to get the "departing" portions of the salutes done.
The way that I'd call it is "If you are WITH another person then the senior of the group is the only one who counts and the GROUPS salute as per the relationships between the senior members and it is the senior members who salute for the GROUPS. However if you are only with another person then you are a group of individuals and have to follow the code as individuals."
Face it, if you are a group led by a Lieutenant that is marching past the Camp Commandant and the Camp Sergeant Major then it is only the person in charge who salutes and it is only the Camp Commandant who returns the salute. (It would be highly improper for the Lieutenant to salute the Camp Sergeant Major and s/he would have to complete their salute to the Camp Commandant BEFORE they could return the salute of the Camp Sergeant Major [who would have to wait for the Camp Commandant to return the Lieutenant's salute before s/he saluted the Lieutenant as it would be highly improper for them to return a salute directed at the Camp Commandant].)
If you had two groups with Group 1 composed of an E-1, E-3, E-5, E-7, E-9, P-2, O-4, and an 0-6 and Group 2 composed of an E-2, E-4, E-6, E-8, O-1, O-3, O-5, and an O-7 and if each pair of salutes took 30 seconds to complete, you would spend almost an hour (56 minutes to be exact) just getting the "meeting" portions of the salutes done AND, since you would (obviously) have had to stand still to get those salutes done then you would have to spend the same length of time to get the "departing" portions of the salutes done.
(1)
(0)
(1)
(0)
(0)
(0)
Read This Next