Avatar feed
Responses: 5
1px xxx
Suspended Profile
Edited >1 y ago
95446d5
SFC Joe S. Davis Jr., MSM, DSL - I don't understand . . . why a belt fed grenade launcher instead of a belt fed mortar? The Nazis fielded a high rate of fire M-19 Maschinengranatwerfer in WWII. The Soviets fielded the F-82 then 2B9 (water cooled) then 2B9M (air cooled) Vasilek breach loading clip fed automatic mortars. Several other countries produced variants of the 2B9M w/ HEAT, HE, thermobaric, and other special rounds. The French build the most curious looking yet indefatigable 120mm Dragonfire . . . which the USMC extensively adapted for their Dragonfire II 120mm Scorpion series automatically fired mortars. These weapons have distinct advantages over grenade launchers in mountainous terrain and achieve far longer range. Why the focus on automatic belt fed grenade launchers instead of automatic belt fed breach loaded mortar launchers? Why focus on auto grenade vs auto mortar launchers? Warmest, Sandy :)
p.s. While the ELBIT SPEAR is not fully automatic there is no reason it could not be made so.

ELBIT SPEAR: http://youtu.be/8JnX2NrrnC0
DRAGONFIRE: http://youtu.be/KL192U_tlVU

LTC Jason Mackay CSM Charles Hayden LTC Stephen C.
LTC Jason Mackay
LTC Jason Mackay
>1 y
1LT Sandy Annala mortar systems mounted on vehicles also tear up the vehicle suspension. I've spent the last few months trying to get mortar tracks fixed. I know what they do to tracks that are much more robust with torsion bars and road arms, honestly don't know how the Stryker mortar carrier will hold up over time, never mind how a Land Rover Defender 500 will stand up with a 120mm Over a single light truck axle, unless it swivels over the back and the base plate goes on the ground to fire....then in the end, is it really mounted? We do have low recoil systems in development and is HMMWV mounted, but the MK19 is filling a different role. In the video you posted, these mortars are being used as fire support in lieu of cannon. The MK19 is more of a crew served weapon to get you out beyond .50 cal range with small area effects. Dismounted infantry are not going to be employing MK19s unless their Strykers are in close support. The systems you have posted would be supporting Airborne, Air Assault, or purely light infantry that still have dismounted mortars they have to move at times by hand.
(0)
Reply
(0)
SSgt Carpenter
SSgt (Join to see)
>1 y
1LT Sandy Annala - Ma'am that truck pictured is still a dedicated mortar carrier, much like the dedicated TOW carriers. The MK19 can be mounted on the same tripod or turret mount as Ma Deuce. I believe the Bradley fighting vehicle and the Strykers fill the slot that a mobile mortar might. If you wanted to argue that we should have auto mortars in our inventory, I wouldn't be prepared to argue you. However, I do believe that they couldn't supplant the MK19.
(0)
Reply
(0)
1px xxx
Suspended Profile
>1 y
LTC Jason Mackay - Well, I can grasp some of the basic principles, the limits of practical application are way beyond my knowledge. What I recall is ELBIT claims to have reduced the 120mm's firing recoil impulse load from 30 tons to less than 10 tons. Is this enough to avoid tearing up whatever may be the heaviest axels available? Are they being too optimistic and the 120mm recoil must inevitably destroy even tracked vehicles? What if we can reduce the recoil impulse further - how much can your axels handle? What about hardening the floor and dropping quick acting hydraulic jacks? Warmest Regards, Sandy
LTC Jason Mackay
LTC Jason Mackay
>1 y
1LT Sandy Annala - all things are possible if you can mitigate limiting factors to the point of negligibility. Of course we look to science, technology, and engineering to do that. Someday.
(0)
Reply
(0)
LTC Stephen F.
2
2
0
Facing a belt-fed grenade machine gun as an infantryman is a very somber idea SFC Joe S. Davis Jr., MSM, DSL. My druthers would be in order of priority: 1st accuracy; 2nd reliability; 3rd ease of assembly; 4th cyclic rate; and 5th muzzle velocity.
(2)
Comment
(0)
Avatar small
PO1 William "Chip" Nagel
2
2
0
Capt'n Ray Wallace would think he was in Heaven. That man loved the Grenade Gun we had on the Arkansas and it only shot one at a time.
(2)
Comment
(0)
Avatar small

Join nearly 2 million former and current members of the US military, just like you.

close