Posted on Sep 30, 2015
Grandson of atomic bomb crewman writes of hibakusha horrors
6.35K
165
38
34
34
0
Edited 8 y ago
Posted 9 y ago
Responses: 17
COL Mikel J. Burroughs - Mikel; Regardless of any other factor, it is indisputable that dropping the atomic bombs most likely resulted in a net SAVING of Japanese lives.
True, there was a "Peace Party" that was attempting to negotiate a "surrender with face" but there was also a "War Party" that felt that there was ABSOLUTELY no way that any surrender was acceptable and that it was better for the country to go down in flames than yield to the United Nations.
On balance, since the "War Party" controlled the Japanese military (and wouldn't have had any compunctions about assassinating the Emperor) and the "Peace Party" didn't control any significant forces, had the bombs NOT been dropped - stirring the Emperor to actually take a visible, personal, role in the government of Japan, the "War Party" would have prevailed.
As it was, the "War Party" only missed stopping the Emperor's broadcast of Japan's surrender by the narrowest of margins. (Once having failed to stop it, the "War Party" had no option but to obey the will of the Emperor.)
True, there was a "Peace Party" that was attempting to negotiate a "surrender with face" but there was also a "War Party" that felt that there was ABSOLUTELY no way that any surrender was acceptable and that it was better for the country to go down in flames than yield to the United Nations.
On balance, since the "War Party" controlled the Japanese military (and wouldn't have had any compunctions about assassinating the Emperor) and the "Peace Party" didn't control any significant forces, had the bombs NOT been dropped - stirring the Emperor to actually take a visible, personal, role in the government of Japan, the "War Party" would have prevailed.
As it was, the "War Party" only missed stopping the Emperor's broadcast of Japan's surrender by the narrowest of margins. (Once having failed to stop it, the "War Party" had no option but to obey the will of the Emperor.)
(11)
(0)
PO3 Donald Murphy
And even after the surrender, Admiral Onishi and a squadron's worth of planes attacked the US Fleet, prompting Admiral Halsey to make his famous end of war speech "if any Japanese airplanes appear, shoot them down in a friendly way."
(3)
(0)
1SG Dennis Graves
Col, thanks for this enlightenment of historical events. I believe other will find it enjoyable also
(1)
(0)
COL Mikel J. Burroughs thanks for this historical thread, I watched last week the only dual survivor of the bomb attacks. This will be debatable until the end of time. I am glad the war is over and peace is reigns supreme.
(10)
(0)
PO3 Donald Murphy
Its an easy debate to win/end. They were being fire bombed nightly because they wouldn't surrender. Had they not been atom bombed, they would have ceased to exist as a people/nation. Colonel Le May crossed that golden line where you come up with the most efficient way to kill your enemy and win the war. Fire bombs.
The book "A Torch To The Enemy" goes into every Japanese city that was bombed, how much square footage was burnt and how many people died. Hiroshima an Nagasaki were drops in the bucket. REALLY.
The book "A Torch To The Enemy" goes into every Japanese city that was bombed, how much square footage was burnt and how many people died. Hiroshima an Nagasaki were drops in the bucket. REALLY.
(1)
(0)
Read This Next