Posted on Mar 19, 2015
Why our “Take a Motrin” approach could be hurting our troops: Part I of II
14.1K
145
66
36
36
0
All of us have experienced – or at least heard about – this type of situation unfolding overseas: a troop suffers a potential head injury, is hastily evaluated (despite best intentions), and is put back into the fight too early. “Take a Motrin,” the adage goes, where unit-level medics give troops a few Motrin, ask them to recite the alphabet backwards, and tell them to shake it off. Added to this is that military personnel have a tough mentality; they too often avoid admitting they’re hurt or in pain until it becomes unbearable. But by then, it could be too late, and tragedy becomes almost inevitable.
The unit-level “screening” tests conducted in the military actually do not tell us much about the true brain injury that may have occurred. For example, we don’t know whether taking a Motrin helps or actually HURTS a troop with a serious head injury. In a literal sense, this means a troop could have a TBI, and the military’s protocols could actually be hurting him/her. It’s true, as much as I wish it wasn’t.
What we need is a test that tells us whether this troop is truly injured, how bad the injury is, and how we may be able to best treat him. Magnetic Resonance Spectroscopy (MRS) is such a test. It’s a unique version of an MRI that measures the chemicals in the brain – a completely harmless procedure that can tell if chemicals in the brain have changed. A renowned Harvard brain scientist, Dr. Alex Lin, is spearheading an ambitious study to bring this test to the DoD – a change that would save the lives of countless members from among our military community.
Currently, we can look at MRS studies in mice to see how their brain chemicals change after head trauma from a blast. We can also look at MRS studies from NFL players and professional soccer players, and make predictions about what chemicals might change in military troops due to a blast. However, scientists don’t know exactly how the brain responds to an IED blast versus a high-impact football tackle. This requires us to further investigate how an IED blast specifically affects troops’ brains.
Through Dr. Lin’s MRS study, it will be possible to not only determine what chemicals in the brain change due to an IED blast, but also start the process of developing new treatments that could improve – and ultimately save – troops’ lives on the battlefield and years later at home, after they have taken off the uniform.
Perhaps most groundbreaking for readiness across the DoD today, these MRS studies will also allow doctors to easily identify troops at risk for PERMANENT damage if they are hit by another blast – thus preventing troops from returning to the fight before they are ready.
-- How you can do your part to save troops’ lives –
While these studies are sometimes enigmatic, they are critical in that they enable us to learn what we don’t know. The success of Dr. Lin’s study ultimately requires active troops and veterans to volunteer a few hours of their time to be scanned. Being that I am a veteran who is no longer serving, the decision to take three hours to get my brain scanned was easy – the whole time I was thinking, “I am doing my part to save the lives of my brothers and sisters in arms.” The medical community is working to equip line medics with better diagnostic tests and tools to protect troops suffering from a TBI, and as individuals we can all play a role in pushing this process forward.
Dr. Lin in Boston, MA is conducting this study. If you are in the New England area, or are willing to travel to do your part just like I did, please say so by posting a response in this thread, or by clicking this link: http://bit.ly/bwh_study
In my Part II follow-up in this series, I will share my own experience going through this study with Dr. Lin. Coming soon!
The unit-level “screening” tests conducted in the military actually do not tell us much about the true brain injury that may have occurred. For example, we don’t know whether taking a Motrin helps or actually HURTS a troop with a serious head injury. In a literal sense, this means a troop could have a TBI, and the military’s protocols could actually be hurting him/her. It’s true, as much as I wish it wasn’t.
What we need is a test that tells us whether this troop is truly injured, how bad the injury is, and how we may be able to best treat him. Magnetic Resonance Spectroscopy (MRS) is such a test. It’s a unique version of an MRI that measures the chemicals in the brain – a completely harmless procedure that can tell if chemicals in the brain have changed. A renowned Harvard brain scientist, Dr. Alex Lin, is spearheading an ambitious study to bring this test to the DoD – a change that would save the lives of countless members from among our military community.
Currently, we can look at MRS studies in mice to see how their brain chemicals change after head trauma from a blast. We can also look at MRS studies from NFL players and professional soccer players, and make predictions about what chemicals might change in military troops due to a blast. However, scientists don’t know exactly how the brain responds to an IED blast versus a high-impact football tackle. This requires us to further investigate how an IED blast specifically affects troops’ brains.
Through Dr. Lin’s MRS study, it will be possible to not only determine what chemicals in the brain change due to an IED blast, but also start the process of developing new treatments that could improve – and ultimately save – troops’ lives on the battlefield and years later at home, after they have taken off the uniform.
Perhaps most groundbreaking for readiness across the DoD today, these MRS studies will also allow doctors to easily identify troops at risk for PERMANENT damage if they are hit by another blast – thus preventing troops from returning to the fight before they are ready.
-- How you can do your part to save troops’ lives –
While these studies are sometimes enigmatic, they are critical in that they enable us to learn what we don’t know. The success of Dr. Lin’s study ultimately requires active troops and veterans to volunteer a few hours of their time to be scanned. Being that I am a veteran who is no longer serving, the decision to take three hours to get my brain scanned was easy – the whole time I was thinking, “I am doing my part to save the lives of my brothers and sisters in arms.” The medical community is working to equip line medics with better diagnostic tests and tools to protect troops suffering from a TBI, and as individuals we can all play a role in pushing this process forward.
Dr. Lin in Boston, MA is conducting this study. If you are in the New England area, or are willing to travel to do your part just like I did, please say so by posting a response in this thread, or by clicking this link: http://bit.ly/bwh_study
In my Part II follow-up in this series, I will share my own experience going through this study with Dr. Lin. Coming soon!
Posted >1 y ago
Responses: 34
The mentality has to change, but it has to be TOP driven. Until the CoS and SMA start bringing the pain down to the lower levels in regards to troop care and accountability, this will continue, and more troops will suffer the consequences. Also knowing the answers to questions upon redeployment screening, doesn't help with identifying those with issues until it's too late. Everyone wants to be in the game; problem is leaders need to ID quickly and substitute those that cannot be in the game, and give them time to heal. How much of this current mentality of "suck it up" is costing troops lives? The Army needs to be hard, but there's a THIN line between HOOAH and Stupidity. Both will get you messed up pretty quick.
(2)
(0)
CSM Charles Hayden
Troops need to be “bullet proofed” from the chain of command when they report an injury!
(0)
(0)
One of the advantages (I guess) of being an aviator is I was very obedient to the command, "no self medication", which kept me from overdoing it on anything. And, the fact that aviators get (or use to get) excellent medical care and availability of care providers made it so that not self medicating was not really a problem. This comment is not meant as a brag, I was in the infantry (airborne) for 5 years before I went to flight school and am very familiar with the aches and pains of being a grunt. That's why I went to flight school.
(2)
(0)
A concussion is not something you can just shake off. No matter how much you try, when the head is traumatized, the only thing you can do immediately is remove the person from the situation. In combat, when is that possible? Never. So you end up with a soldier who has a headache, nausea, dizziness, and is not in full control of their mental faculties in the fight. Despite best intentions, they are going to be a detriment not only to themselves, but to their team.
There is also a social issue with these things. As MAJ (Join to see) mentioned the mentality of lead by example. Nobody wants to be accused of being cowardly. Nobody wants to appear weak in front of their comrades at arms, or worse still the enemy. The problem is when you have a head trauma, you are weak. Your body is reacting to a trauma, and everything else falls by the wayside. In these situations, the best thing that can be done is to properly evaluate that soldier.
I am glad that this study is being conducted. I hope that it does lead to changes in the way head trauma is diagnosed and treated. I hope that it leads to the saving of lives.
There is also a social issue with these things. As MAJ (Join to see) mentioned the mentality of lead by example. Nobody wants to be accused of being cowardly. Nobody wants to appear weak in front of their comrades at arms, or worse still the enemy. The problem is when you have a head trauma, you are weak. Your body is reacting to a trauma, and everything else falls by the wayside. In these situations, the best thing that can be done is to properly evaluate that soldier.
I am glad that this study is being conducted. I hope that it does lead to changes in the way head trauma is diagnosed and treated. I hope that it leads to the saving of lives.
(2)
(0)
Great article and I would be interested to see how many former vets can benefit from this research!!!
(2)
(0)
SPC David Shaffer
Sgt Richard Martin I hope they do as well. I'm very excited that they are finally taking this problem seriously.
(1)
(0)
You know, I came into the military at a late age. The Drills always said, "DO NOT JUMP OFF THE TANK. Slide down the front of the tank." Yeah yeah yeah....Now, I have named my left knee Snap and my right knee crackle. My back has arthritis and my neck has bulging disks. I have a P2 profile because when I would do situps it sounded like my back was snapping everytime I did one. At first the profile said no running, I made them change it to run at own pace and I could do the 2 mile run. I run the run in about 15 minutes (I have 1842 to complete the run) I usually cannot move real well for about 3 days after. I have a TBI (my leadership never put me in for a PH for), my wife and daughter remind me of things we have done when I tell them "we should go to this place!" "Dad we went there when we first moved here." "Ohh, did we like it?" Yeah we did. There are days I am clear, I remember things, a lot of times they are painful things like in Iraq, then there are some good things like friends or family. My body now has a pin in my thumb where I broke it in two places and torn the ligaments. My leg was broke in OSUT, but I never went to get seen until it was too late and healing and so they gave me a profile and I motrin and I was able to graduate with my class. My aorta was torn in an explosion and it healed, they never found that until I went in for an emergency appendectomy and they did some scan and found the scar tissue. There are parts of me that I have not had checked out that I KNOW are wrong with me.
Would I say that the mindset will hurt me? Yeah, it is going to kill me I know. If it doesn't then I need to ensure that I have it all documented before I retire so my wife and daughter get paid for it when it finally does. When you are older, and trained to "rub dirt in it" or drink water, drive on" or "take motrin" it is hard to remember to get things fixed when the time comes.
It is even HARDER to make sure that your new privates want to get EVERYTHING looked at. I do encourage them to do so though. (Another reason I am so glad to be in recruiting now, no privates). The mindset is just so hard to overcome, I am just so one tracked. Maybe someday I can think normal again.
Would I say that the mindset will hurt me? Yeah, it is going to kill me I know. If it doesn't then I need to ensure that I have it all documented before I retire so my wife and daughter get paid for it when it finally does. When you are older, and trained to "rub dirt in it" or drink water, drive on" or "take motrin" it is hard to remember to get things fixed when the time comes.
It is even HARDER to make sure that your new privates want to get EVERYTHING looked at. I do encourage them to do so though. (Another reason I am so glad to be in recruiting now, no privates). The mindset is just so hard to overcome, I am just so one tracked. Maybe someday I can think normal again.
(1)
(0)
I knew of a young soldier die because they did not diagnose he needed and appendectomy. They gave him Moltrin and told him to suck it up.
(1)
(0)
CPT Aaron Kletzing -- How you can do your part to save troops’ lives – I didn't save their lives but I made a couple of LTCs go though the concussion testing after they were at an Afghan Police compound that was attacked with a few suicide bombers and a lot of explosives. They didn't want to do it. I think they thought they were to important to the mission. But you could tell by their eyes that they were jacked up. I escorted them to the BAS to get tested. Afterwords they thanked me for making them go. They failed miserably and they thought they were OK. I did this because when I got hit by an IED, no one really did anything for me. I was all jacked up and they made me go out on combat patrols the next day. I had a 1SG who took me aside when I was pushing it to hard right after coming back from a back operation. She told me the Army doesn't care about me (or anyone). There is always someone to replace you, so you have to take care of yourself. I told the two LTCs my little story. That is how I got them to the BAS.
(1)
(0)
Read This Next