Should I be flagged or should it be removed?

2018-10-30T08:07:07-04:00

I trust the leaders on here from the advice I've read in the past, so if I'm wrong just set me straight. So here is my issue. The company conducted hieght and weight after the pt test(272) and I failed. After being flagged I saw my 5500 on my psg desk and seen my hieght was wrong by an inch. I brought it up to my psg so he verified by remeasurin. he talked with 1sg about the issue and 1sg said it was a record and cannot be changed and even if he removed the flag I would still need to go back to the promotion board. I think that the flag is erronious and should be removed. ....thoughts?

Response by SFC Private RallyPoint Member made Oct 30 at 2018 9:14 AM

2018-10-30T09:14:06-04:00

Your flag should be removed favorably because it was erroneously placed. A quick talk with your unit S1 should clear that up for your 1SG. While 1SGs are the king of admin within a company, they aren't always familiar with these more unusual cases.
If you look in the promotion reg, this falls under a flag resolving and the SM is not at fault.

Response by MSG Private RallyPoint Member made Oct 30 at 2018 12:04 PM

2018-10-30T12:04:52-04:00

If the information on your 5500 was not correct....your height in this case....then your flag should be removed and a redo for your Height and Weight conducted by someone who are unit fitness trainers, certified master fitness trainers, and/or trained in body circumference methodology, as specified in para 2–18c from AR 600-9

Response by SFC Ralph E Kelley made Oct 30 at 2018 3:51 PM

2018-10-30T15:51:20-04:00

What?
Surely people stop growing as soon as they enlist. They never gain weight and certainly never grow taller. What were you thinking? Slap yourself on the wrist and never ever do it again.
If your story checks out about the 1SG checks out and you weren't slouching (not standing tall and straight), the flag should be removed as long as it is verified that your 5500 is incorrect and you aren't slouching. peopel do grow after entering the army but it's usually wider.

Response by SGM Private RallyPoint Member made Oct 31 at 2018 8:12 AM

2018-10-31T08:12:10-04:00

The difference of one inch in height would be a difference of only 0% or 1% in body fat, depending on height, which means you are at max tape for your "real height".
If you stay in long enough, about a third of your screenings will be an inch shorter than what you think your correct height is, especially at NCOES.
While another screening will likely clear it up for you this time, you need to get down to your screening weight or lose some inches on your waist, or you will be dealing with this every 6 months.