Posted on Apr 3, 2014
SGT Ben Keen
6.73K
26
25
2
2
0
Going through my morning RSS feeds, I came across this article talking about how things at Ft Hood are returning to normal following the horrible events that engulfed the base late yesterday.  

The gunman has been identified as SPC Ivan Lopez who served in Iraq and was pending diagnosis for PTSD.  Now while I personally don't have any insight on the history of this service member and why he was still waiting on any sort of a diagnosis, I have to ask, is the Army and the DoD in general taking too long to identify those personal that may need treatment?  For those leaders still on Active Duty, are steps being put in place to ensure the proper time is given to service members to seek treatment? 
Avatar feed
Responses: 9
1SG Visual Information Operations Chief
4
4
0

A lot off people may bash me for this , but this individual (which I personally know since elementary school) was milking the system. I see a lot off holes in his story.

 

(4)
Comment
(0)
SSG Future Operations Officer
SSG (Join to see)
>1 y
I made this conclussion based on the information I've seen in your profile.  Just like how the news has made their conclussion.  You don't have to be wounded or experience traumatic events down range.  Losing his mother and grandfather was probably a traumatic event for him.  For you to make your assumptions based on what you read, I should be entitled to do the same off of your profile.  And we all know how this should have been handled differently.  As soon as that Red Cross message came down, he's chain of command should have been on it to get him to PR for the funeral.  There shouldn't have been no delay or excuses made to that Soldier.  And since you confirmed that his depression related from his mother's and grandfathers death was the start.  What was the start when he was being seen for possible TBI and PTSD before their deaths?  Look, all I'm saying SSG Cadeno, since every body thinks they know everything about everybody, they really don't know shit.  That Soldier needed help and now we will never know whether he received the proper care he deserved whether if it was combat related or state related and now we have a tragedy.  TBI and PTSD was not really known or cared for back when we were in Iraq, correct me if I'm wrong.  But there are a lot of Soldiers complaining about these headaches and symptons related to PTSD.  Just with my experience, I feel the only help I get is by being drugged up.  And let me tell you from my personal experience, I feel more flustered and pissed with the meds I'm on than when I'm off.  The only difference is that my headaches hurt worse when I'm not on them.   
(1)
Reply
(0)
1SG Visual Information Operations Chief
1SG (Join to see)
>1 y

SSG,

 

It seems that you're angered, so I will disengaged by leaving this quote and a few comments.

 

"His actions are mostly related to the unit morale, toxic environment and depression related from his mother's and grandfather's death."

 

I stated this earlier, just as you in a similar way in your recent post. I know what PTS consist off. I know it doesn't  have to be combat related.

Now if you're debating the milking the system comment. Explain to me how Ivan self diagnose himself with TBI when he never saw action. That's what I called trying to milk the system.

SSG Ellington I see that this is a sensitive topic for you. I respect your passion for the topic and your service, so as a gentlemen I agree to disagree.

(0)
Reply
(0)
SSG Future Operations Officer
SSG (Join to see)
>1 y
Same here, I agree to disagree. And I am passionate about this topic.  No hard feelings, this is the type of discussions they should have at the state capital.  People like us should speak on behalf of the one's who can't. 
(2)
Reply
(0)
1SG Visual Information Operations Chief
1SG (Join to see)
>1 y
Those are wise words right there.
(1)
Reply
(0)
Avatar small
SSG Robert Burns
2
2
0

Just because he wasnt diagnosed doesnt mean he wasnt getting treatment.  He was being treated.  Whether or not he had a peice of paper that said he had it or not doesnt change anything.

Its like having a flat tire on your car.  You may not know what is wrong with it yet, but you put air in it (treat it) until you find out.  Whether it's a whole, a nail, bad valve stem, whatever, you are still treating it until you find out the cause.

Or better yet like a cold.  I have a runny nose, and body aches.  I dont have to be diagnosed with the flu to start taking tylenol and theraflu. 

(2)
Comment
(0)
Avatar small
SFC Communications Chief (S6)
1
1
0
You're operating of course under the assumption that the pending PTSD diagnosis was the primary cause for his actions.
(1)
Comment
(0)
Avatar small

Join nearly 2 million former and current members of the US military, just like you.

close