Posted on Jul 12, 2015
SCPO Investigator
5.48K
84
30
5
5
0
1ae639db
In 1970, while a fairly new sailor in San Diego, I let it slip that I wanted to walk in a regularly scheduled, annual parade with some civilian friends to help "demonstrate" against animal abuse. My division CPO said I'd be written up and stand Captain's Mast, if I did. I would have been on weekend Libs and in civvies. Needless to say, I did not go. Granted, this was 1970, at least two worlds away from today in any category you may choose. But is our military still muzzled when it comes to political issues and political campaigns? Can they or should they be allowed to actively participate in such activities? I firmly believe that the upcoming 2016 presidential election has every likelihood of being the most contentious AND the most critically important election in my lifetime, thus far. Do you agree or not, and, if so, how have things changed since 1970, as far as the individual serviceman's or servicewoman's rights to participate in public elections? Thinking back now, I may have been in violation of the UCMJ when I ran for and was elected to my city's Board of Aldermen in the early 1990s. What are or should be the rules in this matter?
Posted in these groups: 6262122778 997339a086 z PoliticsImgres Constitution
Edited >1 y ago
Avatar feed
See Results
Responses: 13
A1C Intelligence Analyst
6
6
0
From what I understand, you can go out and participate in anything, even political rallies. HOWEVER, if you at any time make it known or deliver a statement in support of anything, you CAN NOT do it in the name of your service. In other words, you can say you suppose John Doe for president. What you can't do is say, "I'm in the USAF and I support John Doe for president." Nor can you do it while in uniform.

This is a highly misunderstood topic while serving in the military. But no, your right to free speech or right to assemble has not been taken away from you; it's simply been restricted to only AS A CIVILIAN.
(6)
Comment
(0)
Avatar small
CPT Jack Durish
5
5
0
I really don't have any problem with military personnel exercising the rights enjoyed by any citizen keeping in mind that no citizen has the right to circumvent elections through armed intervention. So long as the military refrains from using the organization, training, and equipment that We the People have provided for our defense and turn them against the lawfully elected government, why not? I can understand some expressing reluctance against giving military personnel the full expression of their rights inasmuch as military personnel tend to be very conservative in their political views. They are sworn to uphold the Constitution and most have a better understanding of that document than most other citizens. Thus, those on the Left would hate to see military personnel speaking their minds freely. Indeed, they would most likely be happy to see military personnel stripped of the right to vote. Keep in mind the impact the military vote has had on critical elections. The most famous example being the reelection of Abraham Lincoln. Without the popular support of the soldiers and sailors of the Union forces, the Democrats would have won that election and Lincoln's replacement would have ended the war, allowed the South to secede in peace, and slavery possibly would still exist today.
(5)
Comment
(0)
SCPO Investigator
SCPO (Join to see)
>1 y
I agree up to one point. To unequivocally state that had a Democrat been elected in 1865, slavery would still exist today, is an incredibly obtuse stretch of the mind. And I sure ain't no Democrat!!!
(0)
Reply
(0)
Avatar small
Sgt Aaron Kennedy, MS
3
3
0
We have Reserve Officers who hold Political Positions which they Campaigned for.

Most notibly the recently retired Col L. Graham, and if i recall correctly one of our Presidents was also a Reserve Col.

You can exersise Free Speech & Assembly, inlcluding Politics, however you may not do so "in uniform" or on behalf of a Service, which are apolitical.
(3)
Comment
(0)
Avatar small

Join nearly 2 million former and current members of the US military, just like you.

close