Posted on Sep 6, 2022
CPL Kevin Noble
11.4K
5
5
2
2
0
My first lipoma appeared while I was deployed in Iraq and I had it removed at a non-VA clinic one month after returning home. Those records no longer exist. Painful lipomas now cover my body and I have been diagnoses with Dercum's Disease. My claim for service connection was denied and I was hoping that it may be reconsidered due to the PACT Act.
Avatar feed
Responses: 2
MSG Intermediate Care Technician
2
2
0
(2)
Comment
(0)
Avatar small
COL Randall C.
1
1
0
CPL Kevin Noble - rather than rehashing, this is very similar to other questions asked here:
https://www.rallypoint.com/answers/why-isn-t-pancreatic-cancer-a-presumptive-condition-related-to-agent-orange-exposure

and here:
https://www.rallypoint.com/answers/is-prostate-cancer-covered-by-the-pact-act-for-va-disability-claims

Bottom line: if it's not listed as a presumptive condition (it's not), then you have to show a service connection. As part of the service connection linkage, if you show that symptoms showed up during service or within one year of leaving the military you MAY have some weight to show a service connection.

However, since you submitted a claim and it was denied, you'll have to come up with additional information (have you tried going back to the clinic, assuming it still exists, and getting records? Was there anything that documented that you had a lipoma appear while in Iraq? Etc.)
(1)
Comment
(0)
CPL Kevin Noble
CPL Kevin Noble
2 y
Thank you for responding to me Sir. I was young and naive, and didn't think much of it when the lump appeared on my thigh. I also didn't realize the importance of having it removed at the VA, and realize now that having it removed at a local walk-in clinic was a mistake. I've attempted to retrieve those records, but the clinic closed and the records were destroyed.

Best regards,
Kevin
(0)
Reply
(0)
COL Randall C.
COL Randall C.
2 y
From what you said, you couldn't have had it removed at the VA (they only treat service connected issues or those that are >50% service disabled). However, the importance of those medical records can't be understated.

I assume you used insurance when you had it removed (Tricare?) and didn't pay for the procedure completely out of pocket. Contact the insurance company to obtain records of the procedure. It's not medical notes, but it should have procedure codes that might bolster an appeal.

You can also obtain sworn testimony from fellow servicemembers, relatives, medical personnel (if any are around), etc. But, keep in mind, every medical issue a Soldier has does not mean it is Service related. I can be, but isn't automatically (unless it is presumptive .. then you just need to show you have it and that you're eligible under the criteria)

I'll caveat anything I say with the standard disclaimer - I'm not a medical professional so take anything I say medically related with a grain of salt.

One of the things you have working against you is that, from what I could see on lipomas and Adiposis-Dolorosa, it has a genetic component and there isn't any good solid evidence of precursor symptoms. However, there are some strong correlations on the medical websites I looked at (NIH.gov, etc.). It is possible that if you have medical documentation of some of these precursors appearing during your Service that it could be grounds for an appeal with new information.

However .. there are a lot of qualifiers there .. possible .. could .. might. I'm sorry to say that you'll have a long hill to climb in proving a service connection if there isn't anything showing that it was there during service.
(0)
Reply
(0)
CPL Kevin Noble
CPL Kevin Noble
2 y
Thank you for your advice Sir.
(0)
Reply
(0)
Avatar small

Join nearly 2 million former and current members of the US military, just like you.

close