Posted on Jun 25, 2015
SCPO Investigator
7.75K
88
37
4
4
0
Avatar feed
See Results
Responses: 15
LTC Bink Romanick
10
10
0
Arrogance, hubris and disregarding his own Intel and ground truth. His splitting of his force with Reno and Benteen led to degragradation of unity and effort.

It's hard to determine if Reno and Brnteen's forces could have turned the tide or just supplied more scalps.

Custer was brave , audacious but egotistical and that was a bad mix against a foe who had been fighting on that terrain for centuries and may have been among the finest light cavalry organizations in the world.

Many of Custer's trroopers were armed with single shot weapons while the native Americans had repeating weapons. This led to a disparate ratio of fire and gave the NA the addition of time. Gen Sheridan's s strategy of annihilation certainly led to a strengthening of resolve.
(10)
Comment
(0)
SPC David S.
SPC David S.
>1 y
You nailed this one sir, Custer's past heroics as the "Boy General" having survived 11 horses being shot out from under him only encouraged his reckless abandon. Certainly Custer's vainglory antics on the battle field seemed to be a family trait as his younger brother Thomas exhibited like wise cockiness. Thomas was a two time recipient of the Medal of Honor. Tragically however George along with two of his brothers, a brother-in-law and a nephew all died at Little Big Horn.
(0)
Reply
(0)
MAJ Ken Landgren
MAJ Ken Landgren
>1 y
Reno = 200 more scalps.
(0)
Reply
(0)
Avatar small
MSgt Robert Pellam
6
6
0
Custer was an interesting leader. During the Civil War his brashness was actually Exulted. Commanders would praise him because a few times his wild charges saved people or lines from crumbling. If his leadership would have reeled him in during the Civil War, and instilled more Discipline instead of promoting his wild behavior would he have followed procedure more?

As far as the battle. Custer made mistakes, but I always wonder if Benteen and Reno could have made a difference if they had not delayed? But in the end it all falls on Custer. I see a leader who ignored sound advice, ignored his troops and pushed them to hard, and failed to make sound decision based on reliable information. When leadership fails, it can be disastrous.
(6)
Comment
(0)
LTC Charles Blasdell
(1)
Reply
(0)
MSgt Robert Pellam
MSgt Robert Pellam
>1 y
LTC Charles Blasdell Excellent Link. Thank you for sharing. I am now engrossed in reading more of them.!
(0)
Reply
(0)
Avatar small
LTC Charles Blasdell
5
5
0
He didn't listen to his scouts. He sent Benteen on a wild goose chase to get him out of the area where Custer anticipated glory in a great victory. He attacked before he had a clear tactical picture. He attacked using tactics that assumed his opponents wouldn't change their tactics...He was in command so yes
(5)
Comment
(0)
MSgt Robert Pellam
MSgt Robert Pellam
>1 y
LTC Charles Blasdell do you think if Custer would have been a better tactician he could have taken Crazy Horse and Sitting Bull's Forces with the company he had, to include Benteen and Reno's Men?
(0)
Reply
(0)
LTC Charles Blasdell
LTC Charles Blasdell
>1 y
His overriding concern was to not let them (the Lakota) get away. He attacked because he feared his command had been discovered and that the encampment on the Little Bighorn would escape. An atlas of the Sioux War is available at this site:
http://usacac.army.mil/organizations/cace/csi/pubs#IndianWar
It details a timeline...
(0)
Reply
(0)
1px xxx
Suspended Profile
>1 y
Don't forget he had a chance to take Gatling Guns with him and decided they did not add a decisive advantage to the battle field vs the difficulty of transporting them......now imagine if he had....
LTC Charles Blasdell
LTC Charles Blasdell
>1 y
In a defensive posture the Gatling guns would have been ok. On the offensive they were a nightmare. He would have been better off taking the Calvary sabers they left behind. The plains tribes had a healthy respect for the "long knives"
(0)
Reply
(0)
Avatar small

Join nearly 2 million former and current members of the US military, just like you.

close