Posted on Feb 18, 2016
Do you feel the National Guard can help in areas with high crime?
9K
70
22
4
4
0
Posted 9 y ago
Responses: 14
The NG would provide a temporary measure of public safety. It would be a short term fix. Due to the racial and socioeconomic issues in Chicago, this would be a PR nightmare for the Guard (and Army in general) and would show a heavy handed measure by the state government that may only raise tensions.
The appropriations spent on such a deployment would be better used to help fund a long term solution. Chicago needs changes in its political culture, dependence on government assistance, family life and economic policies. Chicago is a great city and deserves more than a short term solution of soldiers patrolling its streets. The deployment of troops should be reserved for situations where civil government has either completely failed (broken down/dissolved) or a man-made/natural disaster has expanded beyond the capability of the local/state government to respond.
The appropriations spent on such a deployment would be better used to help fund a long term solution. Chicago needs changes in its political culture, dependence on government assistance, family life and economic policies. Chicago is a great city and deserves more than a short term solution of soldiers patrolling its streets. The deployment of troops should be reserved for situations where civil government has either completely failed (broken down/dissolved) or a man-made/natural disaster has expanded beyond the capability of the local/state government to respond.
(10)
(0)
There is no shortage of cops in Chicago. Crime is persistent because the culture and family systems in the area have broken down to the point that success is the exception, and not the rule.
(7)
(0)
1SG (Join to see)
SPC (Join to see) - It is my job to get it. People want to throw lots of resources on cures, when an once of prevention would go a whole lot further.
(2)
(0)
As Guardsmen, part of our duties is to augment local and state government. Some of us are tasked with NGRF, National Guard Reactionary Forces to augment local law enforcement for civil disturbance. We are deputized by law enforcement. First level of any police department is officer presence. We assist with presence patrols. High crime areas are usually high crime areas, due to lack of police manpower. If you have a large number of troops to pool, your force multiplies. It offers extra eyes and ears to law enforcement. I've worked for the inauguration in 2012, and we've done health and welfare checks during disasters. If we can be used to direct traffic, so a department has the manpower to respond to crimes of a more serious nature, I'd definitely say that is beneficial.
(3)
(0)
SPC (Join to see)
You where in that tiny school too? I agree I just wish they would have trained us better for it like what they are doing for the DNCC in Philly
(0)
(0)
SSgt (Join to see)
We were in the super scary school that had homeless coming in and the damn thing had 10 floors, during fire guard me and my partner got locked in a stairwell. Good times. Plus it was 20 degrees
(0)
(0)
SSgt (Join to see)
Prison Riot Scenario at the 2011 Mock Prison Riot
At the Mock Prison Riot, the entire decommissioned West Virginia Penitentiary is at the disposal of tactical teams who mesaure their skills against their pee...
See, with us, we are extensively trained in civil disturbance. We compete every year in the moundsville mock prison riot, and we validate every year for ngrf. As MPs it is one of our missions. It's three days straight of virtual gladiator wars and we are supervised and graded by wv state police. As well as the wv doc to make sure we are up to par. If we don't make it, we lose the mission and another BN takes over. Some clips from another team going in. So much fun. But, people get roughed up https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=dJAqe_ZuS3A
Look up http://www.mockprisonriot.org
Look up http://www.mockprisonriot.org
(0)
(0)
Read This Next