Posted on Dec 24, 2015
MAJ Ken Landgren
9.84K
11
10
5
5
0
5118dc41
I figured many folks will appreciate the number crunching:

The Defense Department said service members enrolled in the revised TSP would initially receive matching contributions of 1 percent of his or her basic pay. They would be fully vested after two years of service and eligible for additional matching contributions of up to 5 percent after four years of service. The maximum annual contribution is $1500/month. I will provide an analysis of its worth upon the age of 59 1/2 later. One has to crunch the numbers to see the limitations and benefits of this program.

The funds 10 years average rate of returns are G 3.19%, F 4.89%, C 7.72%, S 9.44%, I 4.58%.

Some assumptions recruit is 18 and retires at 38. He/she contributes full amount of $1500/month and stops adding money to the TSP at 38 for retirement. 7.72% will be used. The military matches 5% of the investment This is a traditional IRA and is subject to tax upon withdrawal. From the age of 38-60, there will be no more contributions.

At 38 the value of the fund is $563,332
At 60 the value of the fund is $1,375,056

I want to note the C, S, I funds lost almost 40% in 2008. Most of the burden of funding the TSP falls on the SM.
Posted in these groups: Retirement logo Retirement7a1e50f4 TSP
Edited 9 y ago
Avatar feed
Responses: 2
MAJ Ken Landgren
2
2
0
An unrealistic assumption is an enlisted SM starts investing $1500/month starting on the fifth year of the career.
(2)
Comment
(0)
Avatar small
LTC Yinon Weiss
2
2
0
That doesn't make any sense. If I put in $1500/month for 20 years, I'll have 360,000 even with no matching and no rate of return. Did you mean $1500/year?
(2)
Comment
(0)
MCPO Roger Collins
MCPO Roger Collins
9 y
Is there anyone that has retired at the age of 38 actually achieved that number? I will standby for all the answers in the affirmative.
(0)
Reply
(0)
MCPO Roger Collins
MCPO Roger Collins
9 y
No takers? I wonder why not. If TSP had been available when I was AD, I would have jumped all over it. Basically, the concept is what I used after retirement to accumulate most of the wealth that I have today. Any time some offers to match your savings, jump on it! However, I do believe the numbers cited in the original post are somewhat exaggerated and unrealistic.
(0)
Reply
(0)
Maj Justin Walworth
Maj Justin Walworth
9 y
I was fortunate enough to get both...TSP without match and an early retirement at 16 years. I saved 20% of my gross from college and it's the best decision ever. I think the biggest problem with the all TSP option is that the majority of Americans choose to spend rather than save. I survived the dot com bubble and recession without selling, but those were lonely times. A lot of people make poor financial decisions. Millions own an iPhone but only a small percentage will invest in companies like Apple. This is why we have a growing wealth gap...free will. It time we start teaching the next generation to invest or they're doomed to work themselves to death.
(0)
Reply
(0)
Lt Col John Tringali
Lt Col John Tringali
9 y
I see the problem as a bad 401K... Your Personal Rate of Return *Last 12 Months
– 0.14%

That's my TSP. Fortunately, I had a real retirement which had a rate of return equivalent of $2M over 20 years. Also, I'm drawing on it at 42 instead of 59 1/2. Time is also money.
(0)
Reply
(0)
Avatar small

Join nearly 2 million former and current members of the US military, just like you.

close